Do willful ignorance and the denial of obvious facts win wars?

It’s a well-intentioned effort, and some accomplished people are part of it. Still, when I read about a new initiative to fight “jihadism,” I shook my head. Here we go again with the same fantasy-based activism that has failed again and again, and will do nothing but continue to fail.
The Jerusalem Post reported Saturday that one of the principal people behind this group, the International Freedom Coalition (IFC), touted as a “major achievement” the fact that “the coalition was helping people understand that the problem is jihadism, not Islam or Muslims.” This is like saying that the problem is your engine, not your car. Nevertheless, he plunged headlong into the fashionable wishful thinking, saying: “‘The urgency is that people in the West need to see the enemy stripped of its religious garb. It’s jihadism,’ he said, maintaining that the issue was not Islam itself.”
That’s a “major achievement”? Well, sure, if parroting what has been the establishment line for the last quarter-century is a major achievement, then that qualifies. If repeating a tactic that has failed multiple times is a major achievement, then this project is a breakthrough. If pandering to wishful thinking and propaganda instead of facing unpleasant realities head-on is a major achievement, then the International Freedom Coalition is Nobel Prize-worthy.
Ever since George W. Bush proclaimed, six days after the 9/11 jihad attacks, that “Islam is peace,” non-Muslims have pretended, and continue to pretend, that there is a benign form of Islam that is perfectly compatible with Western secular pluralism. Yet twenty-five years after 9/11, that benign Islam has not materialized, even as Muslim political power has increased. “Moderate Muslim” media personalities lull people into complacency over the airwaves, giving them the impression that the true Islam is reasonable, patriotic, pluralist, and deeply committed to traditional values — the perfect ally for social conservatives. In reality, however, these “moderate” represent no form of Islam that exists on planet Earth, have minuscule (at best) Muslim followings, and exist primarily to foster that complacency.
So why are the people behind this new coalition doing this? The answer is clear. Some people will defy reason, logic, the contents of Islamic teaching and the historical record in order to avoid being called “racist,” “bigoted” and “Islamophobic.” Yet even that is futile; even the organizer of this new initiative is aware that “accusations of Islamophobia… could be leveled against him and the IFC,” despite their efforts to sugarcoat the truth to avoid them.
Back in the real world, “jihadism” doesn’t even exist. It’s just one element of Islam. And it certainly doesn’t exist outside Islam. Go to any Muslim country and you won’t find a single person who will say “Those people are jihadists, not Muslims.” The people who are doing this are just trying to exonerate Islam from the crimes done in its name and in accord with its teachings, and trying to preserve their own self-image as tolerant and non-bigoted.
What motivates the entire endeavor to find some name for this phenomenon other than “Islamic jihad.” People have been taught that decent folk don’t criticize other people’s religions, and that to do so is bigoted and hateful. They can’t bear to think of themselves as bigoted and hateful, so they make excuses for Islam.
Add to this the confusion caused by the fact that there are lots of Muslims who are decent people. Non-Muslims see that and assume, wrongly, that there must be an alternative, benign form of Islam. And so once again, they draw back from calling the thing by its right name. But such a form of Islam doesn’t actually exist. There are just people who are equivalent to nonobservant Jews, Christians, etc.
This group will get nowhere, because what it is fighting, a non-Islamic “jihadism,” does not exist. Since it refuses to face the problem squarely, it will discover that all its efforts to fight “jihadism” founder. Why? Because jihadists will continue to emerge from the Muslims they were counting on to oppose “jihadism,” and they’ll never allow themselves to figure out why that is happening. They’ll also find, to their surprise and chagrin, that the non-jihadist Muslims they ally with won’t turn out to be all that inclined to fight against the jihadists. They’ll never figure out the reason why that is, either.
࿗Infidel࿘ says
Appending the suffix “ism” to islamic terms to make the root words seem to mean the opposite of what they actually mean is one of the most bizarre, surreal linguistic gymnastics I have seen this century
JeffS says
Why is this site called Jihad Watch and not Islam Watch? I’m not trying to be a wise guy; I’m just curious.
Brenrod says
I wonder if there are any actual Muslims in that group, or imams? In fact I can’t remember ever hearing of a Muslim group against jihad, lol.