Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed is proving to be just what his detractors warned he was. “Michigan’s senator-elect El-Sayed demands Gaza war accountability, questions two-state solution,” by Idan Kweller, Jerusalem Post, November 18, 2026:
Addressing the future of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, El-Sayed stopped short of expressing unequivocal support for a two-state solution, saying that Israelis and Palestinians themselves should determine the nature of any eventual agreement.
“There needs to be a free and open Palestinian movement that can negotiate with Jewish Israelis on an equal footing to think about what the ultimate peace should look like,” he said.
“Should that be two states? One state? 25 states? I really don’t know. That’s not a decision for me to make,” he added.

What does El-Sayed want? I suspect he wants a so-called one-state solution, where the 7.8 million Jews of Israel would be expected to live in a single state with the 2 million Israeli Arabs, 2.2 million Arabs in Gaza, 3 million Arabs in Judea and Samaria, and as many millions of Palestinian Arabs who would choose to exercise their so-called Right of Return. In that future “one-state solution,” the Jews would be a minority, and instead of a single Jewish state continuing to exist, it would be transformed into a 23rd Arab state.
According to El-Sayed, Israelis and Palestinians should make the decision jointly, recognizing both peoples’ equal right to self-determination in the land and in a way that ensures a just and peaceful resolution….
The Israelis are not going to negotiate away any part of their ancestral homeland — from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea — to which they have a claim based both on 3500 years of history when Jews have lived on, or in forced exile yearned for, that land, and on the legal title reaffirming that claim that was provided by the League of Nations’ Mandate for Palestine. The Arabs have 22 states; they are not entitled to a 23rd one built on the ruins of the single Jewish state.
El-Sayed wants all American military assistance to the Jewish state to be cut off, leaving Israel vulnerable to its many enemies, as it continues to fight a four-front war, against Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Houthis in Yemen, and against the head of the snake, the Islamic Republic of Iran.
His latest remarks come amid the possibility of a change of government in Israel and make clear that, in his view, even a new administration would be required to confront the question of accountability for actions taken during the war.
Yes, by all means, let not just the Israelis, but all of us consider the “actions taken during the war” by both the IDF and Hamas. The IDF mounted a tremendous campaign to minimize civilian casualties. To this end, it dropped millions of leaflets, sent millions of text messages, and made millions of robocalls, as well as using the “knock-on-the-roof” technique, to warn civilians away from sites about to be targeted. In so doing, of course, it was also alerting Hamas, that allowed it in many cases to escape being hit, but the IDF was willing to do that in order to save the lives of civilians.
Would El-Sayed care to discuss those IDF practices, that led West Point Professor John Spencer, an expert in urban warfare, to conclude that “Israel has done more and implemented more measures to prevent civilian harm than any military in the history of urban warfare”?
Would El-Sayed be willing to examine the atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7 in detail — the babies decapitated, the families tied together and then burned alive, the girls and women raped, stabbed in their vaginas, their breasts sliced off, the genitalia of men cut off, and their eyes gouged out? Would he be willing to discuss how Hamas captors raped, starved, and tortured their Israeli hostages?
Let’s have that discussion El-Sayed claims he wants. Perhaps right on the floor of the Senate, where El-Sayed can discuss to his heart’s content what Hamas did on October 7, 2023, and what the IDF has done in Gaza in the three years since. And on the other side, let Senator Cruz or Senator Tom Cotton or Senator John Fetterman question his every absurd assertion with fact after fact after fact. For Abdulrahman El-Sayed, it will be most unpleasant.
Leave a Reply