Senator-elect Abdul El Sayed is opposed to the very idea of a Jewish state, and insists that the world’s only Jewish state should stop identifying itself with… the Jews. More on his impossible demand can be found here: “Abdul El-Sayed Says Israel Should Not ‘Identify Itself With a Culture or a Faith,’” by Corey Walker, Algemeiner, November 18, 2026:

US Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI) said in a new interview that Israel should not identify itself with a particular culture or religion, renewing questions about his willingness to recognize Jewish national self-determination as he prepares to enter the Senate.
Speaking Tuesday at “The Atlantic Summit: Politics, Power, and What’s Next in Washington,” El-Sayed told Atlantic staff writer Jonathan Lemire that Israel should guarantee equal rights to all its citizens but should not define its national identity through its Jewish heritage.
Instead of saying that Israel should “guarantee equal rights to all its citizens,” which implies that it does not now do so, El-Sayed should have told the truth: “Of course,Israel does guarantee equal rights to all its citizens.”
“I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws,” El-Sayed said….
Why shouldn’t Israel identify with Judaism, with Jewish history, with the Jewish people? That is its reason for being. Without a state of their own to defend them, throughout a long history of exile Jews could be, and often were, persecuted, dispossessed, and murdered. Now they have built their state in their ancestral homeland, turning what had become a “desolate waste,’ as so many 19th century travelers, including Lamartine, Melville, and Twain, testified, into a thriving modern state. It is this which El-Sayed finds unacceptable. He finds nothing wrong, however, with the twenty-two Muslim Arab states that identify completely with Islam and with uruba, or “Arabness,” nor has he expressed a wish that the other 35 Muslim-majority states should stop having Islam as their state religion.
El-Sayed also declined to endorse a specific framework for resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, suggesting that the eventual political arrangement could involve one state, two states, or another configuration….
El-Sayed wants an end to the Jewish state. There are various ways to achieve that goal. One is to create one state, that would include the 8.7 million Jews in Israel, the 2.2 million Arabs in Gaza, the two million Arabs in Israel, and the three million Arabs in Judea and Samaria — a total of 7.2 million Arabs — and in addition, would include millions of Palestinians who would exercise their “right of return,” that would swamp the Jews and ensure an Arab majority . That’s the “one-state solution.”
A second way to end the Jewish state would be to pressure Israel to agree to be squeezed back within the 1949 armistice lines, which would leave it with a nine-mile wide waist from Qalqilya to the sea. With such an Israeli border, an invasion force from the east could slice Israel in two within a matter of hours, before the government could call up the reservists so necessary to Israel’s defense. The state of Palestine would include all the territory which Israel had been forced to give up — Judea, Samaria, and East Jerusalem. Would that state live in peace with an even tinier Israel? Muslim Arabs would not be sated with their 23rd state, the state of “Palestine,” but rather, their appetite for conquering the dimidiated Jewish state would only be whetted, and terrorist attacks could now be launched from a much more advantageous position.
Earlier this year, El-Sayed also told Jewish supporters that he struggled with the question of whether Israel should exist as a Jewish state, questioning how that designation could be consistent with liberal values….
I don’t think El-Sayed “struggled” with the question of Israel’s existence as a Jewish state; he’s against it. What he ought to have been asked is whether he has “struggled” with the legitimacy of all those states that proudly declare themselves to be both “Islamic” and “Arab”? Or does El-Sayed think that the declared identities of the 22 Arab states is just fine?
“I’m sorry for your fear. Obviously, I don’t want to do anything that drives your fear,” he said. “At the end of the day, there’s a difference between safety or lack of safety and comfort.”
“There’s a difference between safety or lack of safety and conduct.” What insight. What depth. Wingèd words.
He went on to argue that Jewish Americans uncomfortable with his rhetoric should instead be uncomfortable with what he described as injustices against Palestinians….
Tu quoque, Jewish Americans. You don’t like what I say about Israel, but I don’t like what you refuse to say about Israel’s terrible treatment of the Palestinians.
The senator-elect’s remarks underscore the tensions surrounding his approach to Israel as he prepares to take his seat in the Senate. While he presents his position as a defense of universal equality and Palestinian self-determination, his insistence that Israel abandon its Jewish national identity raises a separate question: whether he recognizes the Jewish people’s right to exercise national self-determination in the same way he advocates for Palestinians.
That “separate question” has been asked of him, and definitively answered. No, in El-Sayed’s view, the Jewish people have no right to exercise national self-determination through a Jewish state, but the Muslim Arabs have every right to twenty-two such states in which to “exercise national self-determination,” and are hoping for a twenty-third.
The 60% of Jewish voters in Michigan without whose votes El-Sayed would not have been elected should be having buyer’s remorse. He has done none of the things they asked of him. He has not ceased to accuse Israel of committing “genocide.” He has not stopped calling for a complete end to American military aid to the embattled Jewish state. He has not spoken about, much less deplored, the upsurge in antisemitism across the United States. And El-Sayed still cannot bring himself even to say that Israel, as a Jewish state, has a right to exist without conditions.
Frank Anderson says
Standard, normal, common, universal, orthodox Islam lying and deception (taqiyah) in action. With 3700 years of JEWSIH history and millions of murdered Jews to show for it, begrudging the State of Israel to exist in a sea of Billions/Milliard of Muslims is right out of the supremacist and intolerant teaching and practice of “final, perfect, complete and unchangeable” Islam. There is no room for Infidels or tolerance for any who believe differently. Why expect differently? A Muslim is merely telling the truth of what he believes.
Taffy says
In advertising, there is no such thing as bad publicity. Every publication that put AOC on a pedestal because of her stupidity helped slingshot her to the shining star of the Democratic Party. If everyone ignored El Sayed, anything he said, or says or will say would be inconsequential. But keeping him in the news guarantees him prominence in the future.
Frank Anderson says
TRUTH being told.
Siddhi Nasranni says
Power to the TRUTH, & the TRUTH will set you free, only SATANIC Spawns lie & never tell the TRUTH.
Wellington says
A major low point in all of American political history is that this fifth columnist, El-Sayed, is about to become a United States Senator. The Founding Fathers would be appalled that such a man is about to become such.
America was founded on major principles of freedom—political, religious, of the press and otherwise. There is nothing about Islam which corresponds or is compatible to these principles. Nothing.
And long live Israel, the only polity in the Middle East which embodies and enforces the Judeo-Christian concept of what a polity should be, said concept being far, far superior to the Mohammedan concept, and respecting which the about-to-be junior Senator from Michigan fully endorses (and not made any better at all for Michigan and all of America considering the utter fool who is the Senior Senator from Michigan, one Elissa Slotkin, in her own way also a consistent underminer of the Constitution.
Jim says
“Senator-elect Abdul El Sayed is opposed to the very idea of a Jewish state, and insists that the world’s only Jewish state should stop identifying itself with… the Jews.”
What about Jordan, Egypt, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and other countries which identify themselves with Muslims?
Rob Porter says
It’s disgusting that El-Sayed who identifies as a Muslim would imagine that Israel should not identify as Jewish. As to equal rights, in a Muslim country like Saudi Arabia and a Christian you had better keep very quite about it or find you have no rights and then possibly no head.
I cannot accept El-Sayed as anything other than a disgusting Muslim horses ass..
Good luck, U.S. Senate, with this wretched creature in your midst. Expect endless efforts at distraction while he endeavours to impose himself and his Islamic beliefs.
Frank Anderson says
Islam does not recognize that Infidels have ANY rights except to CONVERT, SUBMIT TO HUMILIATION AND SLAVERY OR DIE.
Rob Porter says
Jim, he is Muslim and doesn’t care about logic. Time and again when reading history about the Muslim would I’ve read about the supposedly ‘great centres of Muslim learning,”and wondered where all that ‘wondrous’ Muslim learning went. We have Plato, Socrates and Aristotle and other examples of Western learning, but who thinks of going to Muslims for their ‘wondrous’ thoughts. As it is, as a group they are taught that we humans need only two books for living our lives, the Qur’an and Hadith, so right there you know that Muslim intellect is limited. Read the Qur’an and then decided whether ii would add anything to you life. It’s added nothing to mine other than the knowledge that it is a book for sickly people whose ideas are not compatible with democracy. And you know that El Sayed intellect will be limited.
Siddhi Nasranni says
The Quranic ” Sheeple, just go Bah, bah,bah & follow Satan, Allah & Mohammad.
They are not permitted to think for them selves
At Religious schools they are told what to think, NOT how to think.
There they practice ”The Art of Lying” they are taught that Allah is the best of Deceivers !!!
James Lincoln says
Challenging Israel’s very identity as a Jewish state is a fundamentally different proposition from criticizing its government’s conduct.
Rick Gordon says
This is not news as it has been an obvious belief of El Sayed for some time. Those who voted him voted in favor of hatred for all things Jewish – including Israel and Jews in Michigan.
ploome says
and he may have friends in high places, fighting the jihad with him
“Representative Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY), who is expected to become Speaker of the House in January following the Democrats’ victory in the midterm elections, has called for significant changes in American policy toward Israel, including legislation addressing violence by Jewish residents of Judea and Samaria.”
https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/436785
yes….problem is settler violence…
Billy says
Islam and its Muslims are against ALL Non-Muslims with Muslim discrimination, deceit, segregation, violence, and terrorism using Muslim MONEY and Muslim LIVES as taught by Allah in Islamic Law and in Islam’s Qur’an. Allah in Qur’an 5:51 commands, “O you who have believed[Muslims], DO NOT TAKE the Jews and the Nasara(Christians) as friends. They are friends to one another. And whoever among you takes them as friends, so surely he is of them. Surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.” Also, Allah in Qur’an 5:82 says that Jews are the worst enemies of the Muslims.
Muslims are enemies of Christians and Jews despite the West’s impotent Leaders and Governments. Allah in Qur’an 9:29 commands, “Engage in war with those who do not believe in Allah nor in the last day[Non-Muslims]. Nor forbid what Allah and his messenger forbid[via Islamic Law], nor believe in the religion of the truth[Islam] among those who have given the book[Jews and Christians] until they pay the jizyah[Extortion Payment] out of hand and they are subdued[disgraced].”
Paul says
Yes, Hugh, but, as Hamlet muttered incoherently to Polonius (1599-1601):
“Words, words, words”,
And Marx (1845) kindly helping him out, putting the point clearly:
“philosophers have only interpreted the world…the point…is to change it”;
Then, ever the practical man, Lenin (1901-1902) asking directly:
“What Is to Be Done? Burning Questions of Our Movement”, with Hamlet concurring “That is the question”,
To which Bogart/Woody Allen (1972) shyly volunteered:
“I never saw a dame yet that didn’t understand a good slap in the mouth or a slug from a .45.”
Daniel Bielak says
“Jordan Is the Palestinian Arab State – Anti-Jewish Bigotry Has Caused Much Suffering in the World. Stop It.,” by yours truly [ebook EPUB file]
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zdVOY3PKyzpXpFpoMfQXPBE-_2A9B25W/view?usp=drive_link
Excerpt:
Daniel Bielak says
Content that I just recently added to, “Jordan Is the Palestinian Arab State – Anti-Jewish Bigotry Has Caused Much Suffering in the World. Stop It.,”:
Daniel Bielak says
Furthermore (from, “Jordan Is the Palestinian Arab State – Anti-Jewish Bigotry Has Caused Much Suffering in the World. Stop It.,”: