“This book has served as both a sociological analysis of the Leftist-Islamist alliance and an autobiography of sorts of my experiences navigating it,” writes Craig Considine in his latest volume, When Marx Meets Islam: Navigating Radical Ideologies in Defense of the West. This lucid volume intrigues, not just with insightful analysis of Leftist-Islamist ideological dangers to the modern West, but also with Considine’s personal Damascene Road conversion from Leftist “pawn” to born again critic.
“This book examines a dangerous strategic convergence—the growing alliance between Leftist revolutionaries and Islamist radicals,” writes the prolific author and Rice University professor Considine. In a pleasant surprise for Jihad Watch readers at the David Horowitz Freedom Center, Considine basis his analysis “on David Horowitz’s seminal 2004 work, Unholy Alliance—Radical Islam and the American Left.” This is the more unusual given Considine’s past notoriety to this author and others in the Jihad Watch community as a purveyor of “fantasy Islam.”

Considine notes that Horowitz’s described “alliance is rooted in Manichaeism, a third-century religion that divides the world into stark binaries such as good and evil.” Upon this basis, this alliance has launched a “soft war” against the West, which “threatens the bedrock values of Western civilization” such as “democracy, Enlightenment rationalism,” and “freedom of expression.” Hereby this “alliance exploits the West’s hard-fought freedoms to undermine the West from within, turning the tools of liberal democracies against its very own foundations.”
This war has “taken on new urgency since October 7, 2023,” when Hamas in the Gaza Strip launched a barbarous assault against Israel, a focus of Considine’s analysis. “Following Hamas’s attacks on Israel, this single issue—more than any other—has come to define the soft war” against the West. Here Considine refutes a common “key talking point” that Israel forms a “one-way” relation with America “in which U.S. taxpayer dollars flow to Israel with little return.” By contrast, Israel is “one of the United States’ most enduring and vital partnerships,” involving intelligence sharing, advanced weapons development, and important economic investments. Israel is a Western “forward sentinel, guarding the gates of the Mediterranean periphery of the Middle East and preventing the further westward spread of Islamism into Europe.”
Meanwhile the “Leftist-Islamist alliance…dehumanizes Jews and Israelis to advance its anti-Zionist and anti-American agenda,” Considine warns, as personally experienced at a 2025 Washington, DC, Middle East Forum (MEF) conference. There, the young Israeli diplomat Yaron Lischinsky had attended a panel featuring Considine, who along with this author writes for MEF. Hours later the “pro-Palestinian socialist” Elias Rodriguez murdered Lischinsky and his fiancée, Sarah Milgrim, at “the Capital Jewish Museum, just blocks from the MEF conference.”
The murderous minds behind such assassinations form under the influence of “cultural Marxism,” which originated in the Frankfurt School of interwar Germany, Considine explicates. Here academics such as Max Horkheimer and Theodor W. Adorno “believed that culture, not economics, was the primary tool for maintaining capitalist power.” The subsequent “new generation of Marxists focuses on wielding power within institutions rather than dismantling them” through the famed “long march through the institutions” promulgated by Italian Communist Antonio Gramsci. This new Marxism “proved critical in facilitating alliances between Leftist and Islamist groups, who collectively framed their struggles in terms of oppression from and resistance against Western powers.”
Correspondingly, the “soft war” involves not “traditional bombs and bullets, but rather ideologies and subversion” on a “metaphorical chessboard,” Considine details. Mandated “diversity statements” at Western universities, for example, act as “ideological purity tests” and “a subtle move on the chessboard to eliminate dissent before it can even enter the game.” The “ideological policing” in George Orwell’s 1984 “mirrors contemporary academic environments,” Considine notes from personal experience, one of his numerous references to the alliance’s “Orwellian tactics.”
These narratives cited by Considine include Critical Race Theory (CRT), in which “racism is any disparity observed along racial lines.” “Leftists and Islamists are obsessed” by “White supremacy,” which supposedly permeates “almost every sphere of Western life.” For Considine, classroom conversations, “regardless of my efforts to make them constructive, often devolve into assigning blame to white people.”
“Like CRT, Islamist theories view Western civilization as inherently corrupt, deeply unjust, and racist,” Considine adds. As “victims,” Muslims receive “a higher moral status, a dangerous and false assumption that strips Muslims of their own agency,” which “suppress criticism of Islam.” Islam’s inviolate status “is particularly critical” due to “widespread targeting of Christians…and the stark absence of free speech in Muslim societies.”
“We have reached a point where distinguishing between legitimate criticism of Islamist ideology and genuine prejudice against Muslims has become deliberately blurred,” Considine accurately diagnosis from firsthand experience. His fellow academic and author Nathan Lean, who nefariously denounces all criticism of Islam as “Islamophobia,” once endorsed Considine’s book Muslims in America: Examining the Facts. Their relationship, however, “began to unravel in 2020,” when Considine experienced an intellectual “awakening” and “embraced the liberating spirit of the Abraham Accords” between Israel and various Muslim countries such as the United Arab Emirates (UAE).
Particularly after October 7, 2023, Lean’s response to Considine’s Israel evolution “mirrors Orwell’s warning that Leftists demonize dissent.” Indeed, “Lean’s fury over my shift was so intense that he even contacted Bloomsbury Publishing, the publisher of my book, demanding they remove his endorsement from the back cover.” In Lean’s “inverted moral framework, criticizing jihadist groups or refusing to excuse rocket attacks against Israeli civilians” appears “as hatred of Islam or Muslims themselves,” notwithstanding jihadist Jew-hatred.
Such bias reflects the dominance in academia of the “Orientalism” concept developed by the late Columbia University professor Edward Said in his eponymous 1979 book. He posited, Considine outlines, that Westerners had “deliberately constructed a backward, exotic, and inferior representation of the East (the Orient) to justify Western expansion.” But Muslims throughout history justified their colonialism with “reciprocal and equally reductive ‘Occidentalist’ views from the East.”
The Muslim Ottoman Empire in 1453, for instance, sacked Constantinople, “a major center of Christendom for more than a thousand years,” Considine recalls, part of centuries of Ottoman imperialism in the Balkans. Such Muslim aggressions rarely appear “in university classrooms, as they do not align with the dominant narrative—that the West, White people, Americans, and now Israelis are the true perpetrators of colonization and imperialism.” Rather, acolytes of French philosopher Frantz Fanon “within academia selectively employ anti-colonial theory as a means to ignite a revolution, with the ultimate goal of subverting Western culture.”
In academia and beyond, “Qatar, a small yet disproportionately influential nation,” Considine observes, “has become a central, if often understated, architect in the international front of the Leftist-Islamist alliance.” “The U.S. Department of Education reported that in 2025 alone, Qataris invested $1.1 billion in America universities, making Qatar the largest donor in the world,” alongside contributions to European universities, he documents. Georgetown University specifically has a Hamad bin Khalifa Al-Thani Endowed Chair of Muslin Societies, “named after Qatar’s ruling emir and funded by the Qatari royal family.” Moreover, Qatari royal family members have “enjoyed direct representation at the highest levels of Georgetown’s Board of Directors.”
Additionally, “Hamas’s entire strategic operation, from Gaza’s war zones to the halls of Congress, is underwritten by Qatar,” Considine writes. Alongside Qatari payments to Gaza ($1.1 billion between 2012 and 2018 alone in some estimates), Al Jazeera, Qatar’s “state-funded news organization,” supports Hamas. “Just as the Inner Party” in 1984 “ensured its media arm always aligned with its historical revisionism and propaganda, so, too, does Qatar, through its influential media arm.” Al Jazeera’s Hamas support goes beyond reporting, as Israeli-captured documents in Gaza indicate that six Al Jazeera reporters were Hamas members, who have participated violent acts such as kidnappings and rocket attacks. Unsurprisingly, Considine after his post-October 7, 2023, pro-Isreal advocacy experienced “a complete cessation of invitations from” Al Jazeera.
Considine’s relationship with the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), America’s “most influential Islamist organization,” also “has changed significantly over the years.” He once saw CAIR as “‘civil society actors,’ a testament to how easily one can be misled by carefully cultivated public images.” He “invited CAIR leaders to speak in my classes and openly defended the organization in my books, rejecting claims that it was a terrorist organization,” but his “initial positive engagement” with CAIR turned “to a stark realization of its role within the Leftist-Islamist alliance.”
Such intellectual breakups with people such as Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib present numerous interesting anecdotes in Considine’s life story, well-marked milestones along a personal transformation. His relationships, for example, with the Hizmet movement of the Turkish Sufi Fethullah Gülen and the Ahmadi Muslims, persecuted as heretics by mainstream Muslims, “blossomed” and “thrived for years” with numerous speaking engagements. These supposedly moderate Muslims, though, ruptured relations with Considine following October 7, 2023.
On the “hypothetical battlefield,” Considine writes, “Hizmet members have become effectively ‘silent,’ while the Ahmadis have moved closer to championing Marxist ideology and Islamist geopolitical goals.” They denounce Israel as “genocidal” and an “oppressor” even though free Israel is a rare place where Ahmadis, who have a mosque in Haifa, live in peace. The “jihad of the pen” of supposedly peaceful Ahmadis, is not so benign after all.
Other organizations round out the Leftist-Islamist alliance, such as Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP), Considine writes. JVP’s antizionism functions as the alliance’s “ideological shield by cloaking Marxist ideology in Jewish identity.” Meanwhile Black Lives Matter (BLM) allying with “Islamist factions becomes obvious in considering their shared ideology and enemies.”
Yet Rice University has shown Considine that Leftist and Islamists unite “not on shared values per se but on a shared enemy.” “The absurdity of their convergence is striking,” given the LGBTQ divide between Leftists and “theocratic” Islamists. Nonetheless, in September 2023, the LGBTQ student group Rice Pride severed ties with the Houston’s Hillel chapter, an LGBTQ ally for years, because Hillel rejects partnerships with groups that deny Israel’s right to exist.
Chinese human rights abuses prove to Considine that “every silence and every move made by the Leftist-Islamist alliance is a calculation of power, not of principle.” “A clear double standard” is Leftist-Islamist “silence surrounding China’s” genocide of the Uyghurs. For the alliance, human rights are merely a “tactical instrument.”
Meanwhile a “demographic crisis” influences the European Union’s “soft war,” Considine warns. Hungary’s Migration Research Institute, “affiliated with the prestigious Mathias Corvinus Collegium, estimates roughly 900 uncontrolled ‘no-go zones’ for non-Muslims” in Europe. In such “enclaves, neighborhoods, and urban pockets,” secular law cedes to “parallel Islamist authority.”
For winning the “soft war,” Considine turns to Karl Popper, author of The Open Society and Its Enemies. His “main proposition was that tolerant individuals may tolerate intolerance, but the intolerant, conversely, will not extend the same courtesy,” and thus an “open society” in this paradox “risks being devoured by the very forces it tolerates.” Popper “stipulated that tolerant members of society should first engage with intolerant ideas through rational argument,” but ultimately “a tolerant society possesses the right to self-defense in extreme circumstances.” The “boundary of permissibility is crossed,” Considine concludes, with “actions that incite violence, disrupt institutions, and undermine bedrock principles of liberal democracy.”
For an ideological counteroffensive, Considine demands academic “initiatives that expose students to a range of intellectual and political viewpoints.” Currently in academia, “conservative and centrist perspectives…are virtually nonexistent.” Course requirements should include “Western civilization, American civics, constitutional principles, classical philosophy, and the dangers of totalitarian ideologies like communism and Islamism.”
Government actors must also fight ideologically for freedom. “Local, state, and national governmental entities should vigorously investigate any organizations” for material or ideological terrorism support, Considine stipulates. This includes strengthening “laws like the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) to ensure full disclosure of nefarious foreign funding” to various civil society actors. As mentioned by Considine, Al Jazeera would be an appropriate candidate for FARA, while MEF has exposed CAIR’s abuse of government funding.
Considine’s recommendations range from home to abroad. “Stricter attention to vetting is essential to ensure that immigrants align with core Western values” while reviving America’s “melting pot” requires “English proficiency exams and civic knowledge tests.” Internationally, he strategizes, “the West must also continue forging positive engagements with less hostile Muslim countries,” as demonstrated, for example, by the Abraham Accords begun in 2020.
As a “pawn,” Considine reflects, he was “easily moved by the flattering treatment of the Leftist-Islamist alliance.” Its “Manichaean worldview,” the one-time Noam Chomsky fan writes, “is attractive to many not only for its simplicity but also for its moral certainty,” where “thinking about the world and all its complexity quite easy.” Considine thus became “keenly aware of how easily a young Westerner and U.S. citizen can be drawn to radical ideologies.”
Considine is now a self-professed “knight,” the “piece that moves unexpectedly, in a nonlinear trajectory, beyond the predictable patterns of conflict.” “The well-being of the U.S.-Israel alliance—and of Western civilization itself—hinges on our commitment to the values that made us free,” he commandingly proclaims; “What will be your next move?” A good next move would be to read Considine’s book.
England Invaded says
This cheered me up though. Need much more –
http://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16306037/Councillor-seriously-injured-stabbing-Bradford