Worse and worse: In Italy some naïve bishops have decided to do their part for the interfaith racket, by teaching their flock about the “true” Islam, the Good Islam, the Islam whose Qur’an is the “revealed Word of God,” the Islam that evil islamophobes try to keep hidden. More on this madness can be found here: “Italy’s Catholic bishops promote Koran as ‘revealed Word of God’ in schools,” by Gaetano Masciullo, LifeSite News, October 26, 2026:
Italy’s Catholic bishops are promoting a new Islamic education program that describes the Koran as the “revealed Word of God,” while Cardinal Matteo Zuppi has said Catholic religion classes should be treated as a “laboratory of culture and dialogue.”
On October 21, Zuppi, archbishop of Bologna and president of the Italian Bishops’ Conference (CEI), presented the new educational initiative, “Factsheets for Understanding Islam,” at an event in the Palazzo Borromeo – the seat of the Italian Embassy to the Holy See in Rome. Promoted jointly by the CEI, the Pontifical Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies, and the Italian diplomatic mission, the program is designed for teachers of Catholic religion classes in state schools.
Any Catholic teachers who may have thought there was something threatening about Islam must now get with the program, see Islam for the wonderful religion it is, and teach that to their innocent pupils.
Reflecting on his years as a religion teacher, Zuppi stated: “The only thing that was clear was that there was no need to teach catechism.” For this reason, according to him, Catholic religious education classes in schools should be conceived as a mere “laboratory of culture and dialogue.”
“The eleven sheets go beyond the usual clichés. They begin with ‘What Is Islam?’ and ‘A Brief History of Islam,’ then go on to address faith and theology [and] the Qur’an as the revealed Word of God,” Vatican News reported.
Created by a joint team of Catholic and Muslim experts who negotiated over differences to produce a single, mutually agreed text, the 11-module curriculum presents Islamic doctrine, including describing the Koran as the “revealed word of God,” under the pretext of eradicating “ignorance” and fostering social cohesion.
The Qur’an is not described as “according to Muslims” or “Muslims believe” that “the Qur’an is the revealed word of God.” No, the Qur’an is described in these materials to be used in Catholic schools simply as “the revealed word of God.” That’s what Muslims think. That’s not what Christians think. Or at least not until now, when the good bishops seem determined to confuse their flock. How discombobulating that must be to the young Catholic pupils, who always thought that their religion was the one true one, only to find their religion teachers suggesting that there is another one as well — Islam.
Will those materials about Islam now to be used in Catholic schools include the Qur’anic verses that call for violence against Unbelievers? Of course not. Think of all that will be left out from these classes on Islam. There is, for example, this: “So when you meet the disbelievers in battle, strike their necks until you have thoroughly subdued them, then bind them firmly.” (47:4) Or this: “I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieved, so strike upon the necks and strike from them every fingertip.” (8:12) Or this: “So when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists [Christians are meant, for their belief in the Trinity makes them, in Muslim eyes, polytheists] wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them of every ambush.” (9:5) And there are dozens more of the same violent ilk. And none of them will be included in the Catholic schools’ teaching about Islam.
And will these new materials include the most famous hadith of Muhammad, including those where he explains that “I have been made victorious through terror” and “War is deception”? Will the pupils learn that Muhammad insisted that “Islam is to dominate and not to be dominated”? Or will Archbishop Matteo Zuppi, so eager to prevent “Islamophobia,” want to keep those Qur’anic passages and those hadith from the Church’s innocent charges?
“I would send everyone to school, because there is remarkable ignorance [about Islam]…. The sheets represent the exact opposite of the clash of civilizations,” Zuppi added. He also praised the joint Catholic-Muslim text as a great “antidote to violence and ignorance,” while warning that news headlines critical of Islamic proliferation are “dangerous with islamophobia.”…
How will the texts that Catholic and Muslim clerics prepared jointly serve as an “antidote to violence and ignorance”? It is only keeping hidden the violence that is instinct in the Qur’an, a violence directed at all non-Muslims, including the Catholics who are accused of “shirk” — that is, polytheism — because of their worship of the Trinity. How will Archbishop Zuppi’s materials expose the supposed falsity of that “clash of civilizations” he wants to wave away? Only, it seems, by hiding what the texts and teachings of Islam really contain.
The Muslims must have been beside themselves with joy at the naivete of the bishops they were dealing with. If enough European Christians were to accept the version of Islam that those bishops are eager to disseminate, who will be able to withstand the Muslim conquest of Europe?
Father Alberto Gastaldi, director of the CEI National Office for Education, School, and University, defended the initiative by describing interreligious dialogue as “the very hallmark of Catholic educational commitment” and hailing the classroom as “the first true laboratory of dialogue.”
Interreligious dialogue with Muslims — what may be called interfaith racketeering — always ends up being a farce, with Christians hornswoggled into accepting the sanitized version of Islam that Muslim clerics peddle, while the Muslims constantly complain about “Islamophobia.”
“In a school classroom, learning about Islam through reliable and respectful resources does not mean abandoning one’s own identity. Rather, it means practicing that integral humanism which knows how to make room for the other.… Interreligious dialogue is not an occasional concession,” Gastaldi declared.
“Make room for the other”? When and where, in the last fourteen centuries of Islam’s existence, have Muslims ever “made room for the other”? When have Muslins engaged in real “interreligious dialogue,” instead of deceiving those of other faiths as to Islam’s true intention “to dominate and not to be dominated”? Islam is a faith that was spread by military conquest; everywhere it conquered other lands and peoples, it offered those non-Muslims it conquered, if they were people of the book (Christians and Jews) only three choices: to convert to Islam, to be killed, or to accept the status of “dhimmi,” which allowed them to live and even practice their religion as long as they accepted a host of economic, social, and political disabilities, including the onerous capitation tax known as the “jizyah.”
Bishop Gastaldi claims that “interreligious dialogue” is not “an occasional concession.” No, it isn’t: when that dialogue is with Islam, it is an uninterrupted series of concessions to those whom Oriana Fallaci scornfully described as “the sons of Allah.”
These bishops are blind guides, absolutely the wrong men for this moment in history, where the myrmidons of Islam are by the tens of millions now living inside the historic West, with their numbers steadily increasing, as they undermine Western civilization from within. Cometh the hour, cometh the man, so I have heard it said, but where, and who, is he?
Siddhi Nasranni says
He needs to be removed & taken to a ” Psychiatric Asylum ” in order to get in contact with reality.
Or else he is lying & knows he is lying, but still needs removing. Not fit for purpose.
DavidW says
Congratulations, priests, you have probably excommunicated yourself from the Church by supporting a false book revealed by a false god.
William Kemmler says
Too bad that Pope Provost won’t do a thing about this apostate priest. He’ll just turn the other way and ignore it or worse yet will consider what this apostate priest said to be the truth as he cozies up to his moslem friends. But actually insist on his Priests follow the proper Catholic catechism and dogma? Not so much.
40 rounds says
“antidote to violence and ignorance…” Sure, tell that to the muslims
Wellington says
The Catholic Church of old is the Catholic Church no more. Yes, there are many Catholics who are still reliably “old style” but the hierarchy of the Church is now overwhelmingly controlled by massively ignorant people—and with zero end in sight for this— and since the Church is not a democracy and never has been (and I don’t fault it for this nor will I ever fallaciously assume it should be) the “common folk” have no power to change this, only leave, and leave they should in droves because it should be crystal clear by now that the modern Catholic Church has become an enemy of Western Civilization and even of common sense and sheer survival. All this is beyond mere stupidity. It is evidentiary of malicious willful ignorance.
James Lincoln says
Wellington,
All, very tragically, true.
Kepha says
A lot of us Protetants remain fully ware that the Qur’an contradicts the Scriptures at many points, and bears false witness against the Christian Creed. But we are not many.
But, I’m not sure this pronouncement from some Roman Catholic prelates is evidence of malicious and willful ignorance rather than of just plain ignorance. Two centuries of theological liberalism made most mainline Prostestants so ignorant of the Bible that the mot you could expect from a Bible study was a verse; or, perhaps, if lucky, a pericope. A conservative ANglican I knew lamneted that in his communion, “Scripture” has come to mean “Just the prettier passages of the Psalms”. It seems that since Vatican II, maybe earlier, the RC’s have been going the same route.
It seems that supposedly “educated” Americans are woefully ignorant of Bible content; even if we’re supposedly the land of Bible-thumpers and fundamentalists, and even those better students of Scripture sitting in the “seat of the scornful” (I think of Bill Maher in a go-round with some woefully ignorant and ostensibly Christian pundit) only cherry pick texts out of context to prove how benighted the Bible writers were. I remember talking to a judge from New York who believed that Muslims read the Old Testament and New Testaments–just as Christians bind both Testaments together in one Bible! I have heard people who attended Protestant services all of their lives uncritically accept that the “Bible” recalls young Abram being put in a furnace for breaking his father’s idols (actually, it was preserved in the Midrash Rabbah, and hence transmitted to Islam) after hearing it from a Jewish friend; that there were exactly three wise men name Balthasar, Caspar, and Melchior who brought gifts to the infant Christ recorded in Matthew (actually, it’s from the Golden Legend, a medieval work); etc.
I have seen perfectly idiotic things published by supposedly respectable academic “Scholars”. For instance, in Elaine Pagels (a go-to gal for the History Channel) _Gnostic Gospels_, she posits that the Nag Hammadi maudscpts were hidden by monks persecuted by Athanasius–when Athanasius’ enemies were Arian and Semi-Arians, not Gnostics; and he was the one persecuted; while the Gnostics were a couple of centuries before his time.
Hence, I see these supposed RC “theologians” as sharing the general late modern ignorance of what any traditional theism is all about.
ANd, dear Wellington, is why I agree with you they are a threat to Western Civilization, common sense, and survival.
somehistory says
“Ravenous wolves who will not treat the flock with tenderness.” Refuse to tell the Truth and lead the little kids “astray from the faith.”
Jesus gave a warning to snakes like this one, ‘It would be better to tie a millstone around his neck and be thrown into the Sea”.
“1Jesus said to His disciples, “It is inevitable that stumbling blocks will come, but woe to the one through whom they come! 2It would be better for him to have a millstone hung around his neck and to be thrown into the sea than to cause one of these little ones to stumble. 3Watch yourselves. If your brother sins, rebuke him; and if he repents, forgive him.…”
Walter Sieruk says
In Italy , those Roman Catholic Bishops by their clam that Qur ‘an is the “Revealed Word of God “ by their making that completely false statement , they had really revealed , that in spite of all their religious education they are actually under the spell of Islam deception and therefore , in spiritual darkness. As Isaiah 8:20 reads” To the law and to the Testimony ; If they do speak not according to the word, it is because there is no light in them.”
Sadly, there are a number of apologists for Islam, some are imams and mullahs and strangely enough, even some so called “Christian” leaders as those Bishops who have the false claim that Christians and Muslim both believe in and worship the same God. Therefore, it stands to reason that it’s important to know if this claims valid and true or invalid and false. The facts are that the god of Islam or the Muslims is a single being. In great contrast the God of Christianity, of the Christians consists as the Trinity.
When Jesus prayed He was not “talking to himself’ He was, as God the Son, speaking to God the Father regarding this a good definition of the Bible doctrine of the Trinity is very important
By the Trinity, it means that “Within the essence of the one True God there are Three Persons. Being God the Father. God the Son and God the Holy Spirit” Not three gods in one But Three Distinct Persons in One God. Being the Tri-Personal Nature of God, Matthew 3:13-17. Second Corinthians 13:14. . The Bible teaches, the Father is God, Galatians 1:1.The Son is God, First John 5:20. The Holy Spirit is God, Acts 5:3,4. Not three gods but the one and only Triune God.
As further explained in the Christian book MAJOR BIBLE THEMES by Lewis Sperry Chafer on page 39 which informs the readers that “Many believe that the doctrine of the Trinity in implicit in the use of the word Elohim, as the name of God which is in a plural form and seems to refer to the Triune God. “ Likewise, in the Christian magazine PERHAPS TODAY November/December 2013 on page 8 it reads about Genesis 1:1. “In the beginning God [this is the plural noun Elohim, meaning ‘more than one’] created the heaven and the earth.” Furthermore, a bit of a view of the inner workings of the Trinity together may be seen in that the God the Father raised Jesus from the dead. Romans 10:9,10. Jesus raised Himself from the dead, John 2:19,20. The Holy Spirit raised Jesus from the dead, Romans 8:11.The inner-workings of the Trinity of God may also be seen in the fact that the Father sanctifies, First Thessalonians 5:23. The Son sanctifies, Ephesians 5:26. Hebrews 2:11; 9:12,14;13:12.The Holy Spirit sanctifies ,Romans 15:16. Second Thessalonians 2:13. Getting back to the Bible book of Genesis. In Genesis 1:26 in reads “The God said let US make man in Our image , according to our likeness…” The words are the plural “Us” and “Our.” As in “We the Trinity” For the very next verse, 27, it further reads “So God created man in His own image…” In verse 26 it’s the plural “Us” and “Our” to the singular “His” That is Three Persons in One God.
In conclusion the many apologists and propagandists for Islam who make the claim that Christians and Muslims believe in and worship the same God are make an untrue and outright false claim. For the God of Christianity, Christians and the Bible is not the god of Islam Muslims and the Qur ‘an.
In short, the exposes that those Bishops are wrong , they are in total Biblical error.
Rob Porter says
Very good response, Walter.
When reading Robert Spencer’s book, ‘Not peace but a sword’, I learned that the Catholic Church had decided that Christians and Muslims worship the same God. Having read much of the Qur’an and commentaries, it’s hatred, intolerance, instruction to murder and cruelty, rejection of Christ for who He is, and Muhammad obviously a disgusting pervert, I appreciated that the imbeciles who decided this were not learned Christian men. Having a few years ago watched a documentary on homosexuality within the Vatican, with priest spending a night in sodomy and then doing mass in the morning, I appreciated that evil was alive and sick in the Vatican. You’ve got to be in a pathetic spiritual state if you believe that God does not see your evil ways.
Now these disgusting men, priests, are hedging their bets on Islam taking over. If they did they’d quickly hack off these priest’s heads.
Walter Sieruk says
Those Roman Catholic Bishops who have stated that claim when they said that “The Qur an is the revealed Word of God,” have declared a false claim.
For the Qur ‘an which is the foundation of Islam denies that Jesus is the Son of God. As in the Son of God Who is God the Father. Furthermore, Islam denies the Jesus is God the Son. In addition, Islam denies that Jesus is God. Before going over these three denials of Islam it first should the stated the Bible instructs the way to tell if a prophet or religious teacher is really from and of God or not is do the teachings and doctrines of that prophet of teacher really fit in accord what is found in the Bible ? For if that prophet or teachers and teachers doctrines that are in contradiction to the Bible then that prophet is a false prophet and that religious teacher is a false teacher and thus in doctrinal error and darkness. Likewise if a religion had teachings and doctrines that are in contradiction that is religion is in error also part of the world of darkness and is therefore a false religion. As the Bible instructs in Isaiah 8:20. “To the law of the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” [K.J.V.] With this clearly stated, three things should be known.
First, that Islam denial that Jesus is the Son of God is in great contradiction to the teaching of the Bible . Which reveals the Jesus is the Son of God? As seen in ,for example Matthew 3:16,17. 16:15,16. Luke 1:35. John 3:16-18, 36. First John 2:22,23. 4:14,15. 5:12,13. Second, that Islam denies that Jesus is God the Son is in strong contradiction to the Bible. As found in Hebrews 1:6-8. With emphasis on verse 8. Third, Islam’s denial that Jesus is God is in great contrast to the doctrine and teaching of the Bible. That Jesus is God may be found in ,for example, John 1:1;3. Colossians 1:15-17. 2:9. Romans 9:5 Second Peter 1:1. Titus 2:13. First John 5:20.
Moreover, to further discover that the Bible teachings that Jesus is God all a person has to do is to compare the Old Testament with New Testament to see that Jesus is God. As in comparing Isaiah 45:22,23. with Philippians 2:5-11. Also by comparing Psalm 89:8,9. with Mathew 8:23-27. will reveal that Jesus is God. Likewise, by comparing Psalm 62:5-7 . with First Corinthians 10:4. shows the Deity of Jesus. Even by comparing the News Testament books together will show that Jesus is God. As in comparing Romans 14:12. with John 5:22. will show Jesus to be God. The list can go on but this should be enough, for all who are willing to see the truth, that Jesus is, indeed, the Son of God. That Jesus is God the Son and that Jesus is God.
The imams and mullahs as well as the other apologists for Islam will try to “explain’ this all away by making the claim that the Bible had been corrupted by Christians ,through time, and that’s way the Bible reads as it does.
This claim, very much, underestimate the Power of God to protect and preserve His Word ,through time , and to keep in intact and away from the corruption of men. In conclusion, in light and information of the Bible in can be seen that Islam is a awful and terrible doctrinal error concerning it teaching about the Nature of Jesus and therefore Islam is part of the world of darkness. So Islam with its strong contradictions to the Bible is a false religion, Proverbs 14:12.
So all dear Muslims are thus invited to leave the false religion of Islam and come the and receive the Jesus of the Bible who is the only way to heaven, John 14:6. and the True Light of the world. John 8:12.
Huh!?! says
This is absurd. Nowhere in the Holy Bible is anything about the Quran the holy word of the God of Moses. This is blasphemy. Islam will only use this as another wedge to help destroy the West. Did these Bishop’s ever read anything about Islam. They are ignoring the chants of death to Isreal and death to the West. As noted, these are blind guides.
somehistory says
In fact, the Bible says if anyone adds or subtracts from God’s Word, that person adding or subtracting is ‘accursed.”
“Revelation 22:18-19 states: “I testify to everyone who hears the words of prophecy in this book: If anyone adds to them, God will add to him the plagues described in this book. And if anyone takes away from the words of this book of prophecy, God will take away his share in the tree of life and in the holy city, which are described in this book.” “
GE says
Right! Matthew 5:18- -“not one jot or tittle”.
I really believe that’s where the Roman Catholic Church
has gone wrong–changing things that imo weren’t supposed to be changed. Not in keeping with the way things were done starting out and meant to stay that way. Hence, the great schism.
Also corruption and graft which led to the Reformation, and numerous branches of Protestantism. I’ve heard it said that the Reformation was “the egg the Catholic Church laid.” Just my opinion, of course.
That said, I respect all here at JW and your beliefs.
somehistory says
GE, Jesus also said, “The one faithful in what is least, will be faithful in what is much.”
Paul wrote, “Make sure of all things. Hold fast to what is fine.”
Someone….not in the Bible….said, “Power corrupts” The Catholic church (and to a lesser extent other ‘churches,’) has had enormous power for centuries.
It’s certainly better when the people can see what’s going on in order to make choices about their own lives.
Huh?!? says
I am beginning to think the rise of the anti-Christ will soon be upon us.
GE says
Amen!
Rob Porter says
somehistory, well said again.
Numbers of decades ago, as a young newspaper reporter, I was sitting in a Cape Town courtroom with an older reporter beside me. A man came in for his court appearance, swore to tell the truth and nothing but the truth, so help me God – and then all too obviously began lying through his teeth.
Said the older reporter, “After swearing to tell the truth, so help me God, wouldn’t it make a stunning impression if there was a blue flash through the ceiling and where this liar was standing just a puddle on the floor.”
What a pity this does not happen to these Vatican bishops. What a pitiful group they are- and we can bet that Pope Leo will not refute their garbage. However, its evident from what you’ve quoted from Revelations that these Bishops will suffer consequences.
somehistory says
Thank you ,much Rob.
We can all read the warnings. It’s up to each person to decide whether to believe them, speak and act accordingly and avoid the “blue flash” or to fail to read, or believe and take chances with the “Court.”
There will be a reckoning one day.
Kepha says
Amen!
But, I see Signor Zuppi is Bp, of “red” Bologna. Maybe he’s been infected by the Communist sympathies of his town.
David Grisez says
It is strange and bizarre that Roman Catholic Bishops would claim that the Quran is the Word of God. The Roman Catholic Church of years past would never claim the Quran as being the word of God, the Roman Catholic Church of years past would claim that the Quran was a false book. These Roman Catholic Bishops are going against the very decrees that came out from the Council of Trent which in its statements define what the Roman Catholic Church believes to be the Bible. I am a former Catholic who became a Bible believing Christian.
Wellington says
Here’s something to consider: Saint Thomas Aquinas is the Apostolic Doctor of the Roman Catholic Church. He is treated by the Church as the highest theological and philosophical authority on the matter of doctrine and all that is Catholic.
But Thomas had an extremely negative view of Mohammed, emphasizing as he did (as also John Quincy Adams stated) that Mohammed was rooted in violence and lust and had false prophet written all over him.
So, Pope Leo, all you foolish bishops out there, whether in Italy or elsewhere, and so many other kumbaya Catholics (e.g., those running Catholic Charities), how do you square Aquinas with your recent takes on Islam, Mohammed in particular, and the Koran? And remember, as Mohammed goes so goes all of Islam, including it highest scriptural authority, the Koran.
Westman says
Could it be that this recent legitimizing of Islam by the Catholic church is to save their assets (churches, etc) from destruction by Islamists?
Wellington says
A possibility but I don’t think so. I just see pure stupidity and cravenness of the kind that people with power often demonstrate. Besides, even if so it won’t do any good in the long run since Muslims will either appropriate or destroy such assets anyway.
somehistory says
They could learn a lesson from the alphabet people who helped the muzzies gain political office and power and then found out they couldn’t fly their flag.
Or the pastor wjo tried reasoning with the muzzie mayor and was told to get out of town.
Or they could watch a movie of fiction….”Lake Placid.” Feeding gators will not keep them from eating the hands that feed them.
Tim gallagher says
Islam is the opposite of Christianity. Islam is full of nothing but murderous hate while Christianity calls on people to be tolerant and get along peacefully with other people. Islam is devil worship. Islam the word of god, total bullshit.
Wellington says
I agree, tg, and why I have often referred to Mohammed as the anti-Jesus.
Tim gallagher says
Yes, Wellington, it is absolutely ridiculous for anyone to say that islam is the word of god and Christianity, which is the complete opposite of islam, is also the word of god. It just makes no sense at all. Some of these clergy seem completely brainless. They are on some other planet where logical thought is unknown. Islam is satanically evil and that’s all there is to it. I do worry that too many Christians want to be too nice to everyone and the Muslim thugs take advantage of that softness. I’m a Christian who sees Islam as totally evil.
Westman says
From the LDS website https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/liahona/2002/06/a-latter-day-saint-perspective-on-muhammad?lang=eng :
“Latter-day Saint appreciation of Muhammad’s role in history can also be found in the 1978 First Presidency statement regarding God’s love for all mankind. This declaration specifically mentions Muhammad as one of “the great religious leaders of the world” who received “a portion of God’s light” and affirms that “moral truths were given to [these leaders] by God to enlighten whole nations and to bring a higher level of understanding to individuals.”
It will be interesting when civil strife in Europe with Muslims reaches a violent level, which it ultimately will because of the Islamic command to dominate and subdue the world until all religion is for Islam’s Allah and by extention, Muhammad.
The LDS church has a “infallibility” problem when in comes to its Prophet and its twelve Apostles. When they make a statement, like the First Presidency in 1978, above, essentially saying Muhammad was a prophet and the Quran is revelation from the Abrahamic God, those leaders following are stuck with it and must integrate into their teachings.
The truth is more like, “assumptions were made in ignorance, beginning in the 1800s”. LDS doctrines and Sharia Law are in absolute direct conflict. The core of LDS doctrine allows personal free agency and respect for civic authority that is based in civic law. Islam offers neither.
If there is and LDS person or leader who reads this please explain how a religion originally designed to destroy villages, carry off booty and women(the Infidels), and force people to join, be taxed, or die can be integrated into Christianity? It appears that there is profound ignorance of Islam in leadership.
somehistory says
I am not and never have been LDS.I have read their book, “the Book of Mormon” and found it full of ridiculous nonsense.
I have spoken to many LDS….they don’t like to be called “mormon.”….and found them mostly ignorant of what Jesus commanded which exposes “mormonism” as something less than He commanded.. to them, their book ranks above the Bible.
They are soft spoken and friendly, but they are misguided. The guy who said that the fake ‘prophet’ of slime was the real deal….was either blinded by satan, or he wanted to mislead his followers for some personal desire.
40 rounds says
You’re right, it is silly, and doesn’t deserve the time of day. Had several Mormon friends and they are all in, hook, line, and sinker. Too bad.
somehistory says
Thank you, 40
James Lincoln says
All right, I’ll say it:
Cardinal Matteo Zuppi is a total whack job.
I wish I were wrong…
Walter Sieruk says
Those Roman Calcific Bishops, in spite of that religious education, are in terrible Biblical error when they said the “The Qur ‘an is the “Revealed Word of God .”What they had actually is that they are in a condition of spiritual darkness. For the Bible verse Isaiah 8:20. This instructs “To the law of the testimony. If they do not speak according to the word, it is because there is no light in them.”
As the Quran in 112 teaches “He is God alone: God is the eternal begetteth not…” Likewise, this religious book which is the entire foundation of and for Islam further teaches in 19:35. “It is not befitting to God that He should beget a son.”
In great contrast, the Bible teaches in John 1:14. “The Word was made flesh and dwelt among us, and we beheld His glory , the glory of the only begotten of the Father ,full of grace and truth.” Likewise John 3:16 teaches “For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son… Then just a little further in verse 18 it is written about Jesus Who is “the only begotten Son of God. “ Other places in the Bible further teach that Jesus is the Son of God as in Matthew 16:15:16. Luke 1:35. John 3:36. First John 4:14. 15. 5:14,15.
Moreover, to be even more clear the Bible teaches that Jesus is the Son of God, Who is God the Father. As found in Matthew 3:16,17. First John 2:22,23. 4:14,15. Of course , it ,very much, needs to made even more specific . The Bible teaches that Jesus is also God the Son. As seen in Hebrew 1:8 and First John 5:20.
The imams and mullahs as well as the other apologists for Islam will try to “explain” this all away. As in they will try brush off all those Bible verse off by making the claim that the Bible had been corrupted, through time, by Christians and that’s why the Bible reads as it does. That claim they make actually underestimate the Power of God to protect and keep His Word safe and intact ,through time, and away from the corruption of men.
In conclusion ,with the above instruction of the way to find doctrinal truth in Isaiah 8:20 and in the light of the Bible verse provided it may be clearly seen, by all those who are willing to see, that Islam is in terrible doctrinal error and it is therefore a false religion, Proverbs 14:12. John 14:6.
The Bible has ex[posed that those bishops are terribly wrong when they said that ignorant fool statement.
Walter Sieruk says
Those Roman Catholic Bishops who have stated that claim when they said that “The Qur an is the revealed Word of God,” have declared a false claim.
For the Qur’ an which is the foundation of Islam has blasphemous doctrines such about the actual natural of Jesus is God .
For Islam denies that Jesus is the Son of God. Meaning that Jesus of the only Son of God the Father. That is in blatant contradiction to the information revealed in the Bible.. As found, for example, Matthew 3:16, 17, First John 2:22, 23. Likewise, Jesus is God the Son, as seen in Hebrews 1:8. First John 5:20.
The Deity of the Son taught in the Bible .For in Colossians 2:9 It reads “For In Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form. ” [N.I.V.]
That Jesus is God is further revealed in the Bible in John 1-1-3. Colossians 1:15-17. Romans 9:5 Second Peter 1:1. Titus 2:13 First John 5:20.
So in the Light of the Bible it’s then no surprise that in Islamic countries, the Muslim clerics attempt to discourage the people from reading the Bible, by their words and even owning a Bible, by their actions.
For those Islamic clerics would have no hold or control over the people if they discovered the truth of the sculpture, Bible, Second Timothy 3:16 and the Jesus is the way to heaven, John 14:6.
those Bishops are wrong , they are in terrible and total Biblical error..
Rob Porter says
Thanks Hugh Fitzgerald for your usual candour regarding harsh realities. The Roman Catholic Church has lost its way. This has been evident for some time with Pope Francis a total dead loss, Pope Leo at least the same level of degradation, both barely amounting to ‘men’, who pander to Muslims, saying nothing about Muslim murder of Christians in Nigeria, Sudan, Somalia, Congo, Ethiopia, etc., fail to condemn the Muslim invasions and desecrations inside European, even Italian, churches and cathedrals, decapitation of congregants in France, destruction of churches, and encourage acceptance of more barely civilized migrants who rape and murder. . And now these shockingly gutless imbecile bishops announce the total drivel and lies that the Qur’an is “the Revealed Word of God.” Supposed there are now either two ‘revealed words of God’ or, within the Catholic Church the Bible has lost that status.
One thing is abundantly evident, if God has not yet abandoned the Vatican and Roman Catholic Church, He soon will. “God will not be mocked,” and certainly not by utterly foolish RC bishops. Anyone who like myself for many years has followed jihad Watch and Robert Spencer’s revelations about Islam and the Qur’an, has watched Jay Smith’s dissecting of Islam, the Qur’an, Mecca and Mohammad, reinforced this with Raymond Ibrahim’s views, and read a good amount of the Qur’an, know that Islam and the Qur’an are unadulterated loads of garbage from the pits of hell. Increasingly we learn that Muhammad was not just a warlord, mass murderer, rapist and pedophile, he was a raving pervert who also liked men. Never mind all that, the Vaticans bishops have decided that tIslam’s fraudulent, hate-filled, misogynistic, satan-guided, man-made drop of horse manure is ‘the revealed words of God’. They’ve either gone insane or evil to decide such pathetic nonsense.
‘
Within the RC Church, gone the spirit of the crusades, the courageous spirit that in 1456 at Belgrade drove Janos Hunyadi and his small Christian force of few nights and many untrained civilians to victory over Mehmed 11’s large Muslim army. At night Hunyadi’s army of men and women, under Franciscan friar, Giovani Capistrano, gathered on their fortress walls and sang hymns to the Ottoman savages below. It is evident both before and after battles against the Ottomans in Central Europe, the European armies were Christians and un-ashamedly gave recognition to this at Vienna, Buda, Zenta, Belgrade and Petrovaradin where they smashed the Muslims and sent them packing out of central Europe. Now the Roman Catholic Church sides with the enemy, the one that denies Christ’s deity. Through its own declaration the RC Church is the enemy of Jesus Christ and thus Christianity. What a really stupid lot!
tgusa says
“Heretic” In Christianity, heretic is the name for their type.Within Christianity heretics go back a long way.
abu taleb says
Beware of the false prophet. As the Roman Catholic Church is united under Vatican, the Catholic Church should be treated as the false prophet when some of the Catholic Church elites say some evil things
padiyo says
One can see why this trend is maintained. There is a head of the Catholic Church pouting spouting off similar themes fro the benefit of Allah, while hundreds of devout Christiasn get mercilessly slaughtered in different parts of the world by the despicable follower of Qooran !!!!! The world will watch in horror
jimjames says
The final betrayal of their Faith! Perhaps being homosexual in nature leads ones mentality to slip into delusion and give credibility to a constructed belief system= which Islam certainly is! But then much of what became the Roman Catholic Church was also a construction being that the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth were pruned and cultivated to suit the existence of an empire.
Ralph says
At least there is some voice of reason to counter these nitwits. I refer to German Catholic Bishop Schneider who openly opposed The Pup’s oft-spoken madness praising Islam. These leftist bishops and Pope must watch Tucker Carlson nightly.
KK says
Beware of false teachers who creep into the church. I guess this “priest” never compared sura 9 with the sermon on the mount to see the whom we should follow. Demonically inspired insanity to say the least.
Lisa Tea says
From what I have read in the past, Vatican II already said we worship the same God as the Muslims. Wrong.
I only need to know one verse of the Qur’an to prove this statement a heresy. Qur’an 65:4 gives adult men permission to have sexual relations with pre-pubescent little girls. This explains the British grooming gangs estimated 250,000 teen and pre-teen sexual abuse victims. It also explains the tragic story of the eight-year-old little Yemeni girl who BLED to DEATH on her wedding night in 2013.
No righteous God would ever allow such an abomination, much less enshrine it in holy scriptures.
But wait, there’s more. Qur’an 4:24 permits sex slaves and ‘captives of the right hand.” Remember the Yazidi women and girls being raped by ISIS fighters in Iraq 11 years ago. This verse was their justification.
I left a similar message on a YouTube video yesterday and a Muslim tried to justify these verses to me by arguing the point. A lot of people are going to have a very unpleasant surprise some day.
Lisa Tea says
From what I’ve read, Vatican II already said Christians worship the same God as the Muslims. Wrong!!!
I only need to know one Qur’an verse, 65:4 to know we do not worship the same God. In this despicable verse, Allah gives adult men permission to have sexual relations with pre-pubescent little girls. No righteous God would ever allow such an abomination, much less enshrine it in holy scriptures.
This verse explains the British grooming gangs 250,000 estimated teen and pre-teen sexual abuse and rape victims. It also explains the poor little eight-year-old Yemeni girl who BLED to DEATH on her wedding night in 2013.
After an international outcry embarrassed her government, they tried raising the legal age for marriage to 18 and men rioted in the streets. So, their feckless government dropped the proposed legislation.
Qur’an 4:24 permits sex slaves and ‘captives of the right hand.” Remember the Yazidi women and girls being raped by ISIS fighters in Iraq 11 years ago? This verse provided their justification.
I left a similar comment on a YouTube video yesterday and a Muslim took me to task, calling me ignorant. All I can say is a lot of people are in for a very big surprise someday.
Troybeam says
Magazine/https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/the-catechism-on-islam
The Catechism of the Catholic Church on Islam
Jimmy Akin • 7/1/2002
Listen to the audio version of this content
In the wake of 9/11 it has become more important than ever that Catholics have an accurate view of Islam. A starting point, though not the ending point, is reading what the Catechism of the Catholic Church has to say. It states, “The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims; these profess to hold the faith of Abraham, and together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind’s judge on the last day” (CCC 841).
To understand this, one both has to look at the original context of the quote. The Catechism is not a freshly drafted document. It is in large measure a synthesis of other documents, and one has to look up quotations in the original sources to understand them fully. This is the case for the Catechism’s statement about Muslims, which is taken wholly from Vatican II.
Many find the first part of the quote perplexing: “The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims.” To many this sounds like Muslims can be saved by adhering to Islam. That isn’t what it means, as shown by the original context.
If you look at Lumen Gentium (LG), the Vatican II document from which the quote is drawn, it becomes clear that the phrase is not meant to say that Islam is a method of salvation parallel to Christianity. The quote comes from LG 16, but it is part of a larger context in the document. To appreciate how it fits into the picture, one needs to go back at least as far as LG 13, which starts by proclaiming, “All men are called to belong to the new people of God”—i.e., to the Church. Section 13 concludes by stating, “All men are called to be part of this catholic unity of the people of God. . . . And in different ways to it belong, or are related: the Catholic faithful, others who believe in Christ, and finally all mankind, for all men are called by the grace of God to salvation.”
All mankind is called to the “Catholic unity of the people of God”—in other words, to become Catholics. Some have done so, and so LG states that some “belong to” the Catholic Church while others are related to it “in different ways.” Those who belong to it are “the Catholic faithful,” while those who are related in various ways include “others who believe in Christ” (who are related to the Church in one way) and “all mankind” (who are related to the Church in a different way).
The next three sections of LG (14–16) are taken up with elaborating on these three groups.
LG 14 concerns itself with Catholics. It begins by stating: “This sacred council wishes to turn its attention firstly to the Catholic faithful. Basing itself upon sacred Scripture and Tradition, it teaches that the Church, now sojourning on earth as an exile, is necessary for salvation. . . . Whosoever, therefore, knowing that the Catholic Church was made necessary by Christ, would refuse to enter or to remain in it, could not be saved.”
This of itself repudiates the idea that Islam or any other religions are as good as the Catholic Church. LG 15 turns to non-Catholic Christians and states, “The Church recognizes that in many ways she is linked with those who, being baptized, are honored with the name of Christian, though they do not profess the faith in its entirety [e.g., Protestants] or do not preserve unity of communion with the successor of Peter [e.g., Orthodox].”
Note that it does not say that these Christians are part of the Church, only that they are “linked” to it many ways, some of which it then goes on to name (Scripture, faith in Christ, baptism). While noting that God works among them, LG does not say that it is okay for them to remain where they are: “In all of Christ’s disciples the Spirit arouses the desire to be peacefully united, in the manner determined by Christ, as one flock under one shepherd, and he prompts them to pursue this end.” In other words, God’s grace leads them toward becoming Catholics too.
After this, the attentive reader will scarcely find it plausible that LG is going to present non-Christian religions as on a par with the Church, and it doesn’t.
LG 16 turns to the case of non-Christians, stating, “Finally, those who have not yet received the gospel are related in various ways to the people of God.” The section speaks of the Jewish people in the first place, for they are more closely related to the Church than any other non-Christian religion. It is only after this that the text states, “But the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims.” Note that the subject under discussion is not everyone who is saved. The overarching theme of the passage is how various people are related to the Catholic Church, not how many paths to salvation there are. The Council has been describing people who are progressively more distant from the Church. The Council has already stated that the Church is necessary for salvation. And since it expressly places non-Jewish theists in a distant position from the Church, when we encounter the statement that “the plan of salvation also includes,” we should not understand it as saying that non-Jewish theists are saved.
It means that God desires their salvation and has made plans for their salvation—plans that include giving them graces that lead in the direction of salvation and the Church. But that doesn’t mean that they can be saved by being nothing more than non-Jewish theists.
Within the category of non-Jewish theists, Muslims today hold the first place in that they are the largest such group and have a number of commonalities with Judaism and Christianity, several of which the council goes on to note:
(1) They “profess to hold the faith of Abraham.” The operative word here is “profess”—they claim to hold the faith of Abraham. In reality, their faith is an imperfect version of the faith that comes from Abraham, but they are trying to follow in the footsteps of Abraham, and the Council gives them credit for that.
(2) “Together with us they adore the one, merciful God.” For many, this statement is perplexing. However, as we saw in last issue’s “Brass Tacks” column, God is aware of and acknowledges all that is good and true in the worship offered to him, however imperfect an understanding of him a worshiper may have. While Muslims, like Jews, do not accept the Trinity, they do acknowledge that God is the only true God and that he is merciful. This means that they honor things that are true about God but have a limited understanding of him.
Christians have a fuller understanding of God because he has revealed more to us about himself: specifically, that he is a Trinity. This doctrine cannot be deduced by human reason; it can only be known by revelation.
Failure to accept this revelation of the Christian age does not stop Muslims from worshiping God any more than it stops Jews. It means only that they know less about God and that they have erroneous corollary ideas (for instance, that Jesus is not the Son of God).
To make clear how this works, allow me to take an example from pop culture: Suppose that you and I both knew millionaire Bruce Wayne. I might know, because he revealed it to me, that he is also Batman. You may hear this claim and reject it, in which case you adopt the false corollary belief “Batman is not Bruce Wayne.” That does not mean that you don’t know and relate to either Bruce or Batman, it means only that you misunderstand the relationship between them.
In the same way, one may worship God and honor Jesus as a prophet (which he was) without understanding that Jesus is God. Indeed, many people in his own day did that: They knew the historical Jesus but had a false understanding of his identity.
(3) Muslims recognize that God is “mankind’s judge on the last day.” This is another link they have to biblical faith. Muslims may have erroneous ideas about some of the things that will occur before, after, or around this event, but that much they have right.
Additional elements of truth that Muslims have are listed in another conciliar document (Nostra Aetate 3), but in no place does the Council indicate that Islam—or Judaism or any non-Christian religion—is a path of salvation. There may be elements of truth in these religions, and God may give his grace to whomever he wants, non-Christian religions aren’t vehicles of salvation.
Some in these religions can be saved, but not because of their religions. This is underlined in the document Dominus Jesus that was released by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in 2000.
According to the document, “It would be contrary to the faith to consider the Church as one way of salvation alongside those constituted by the other religions, seen as complementary to the Church or substantially equivalent to her” (DJ 21).
Further, “If it is true that the followers of other religions can receive divine grace, it is also certain that objectively speaking they are in a gravely deficient situation in comparison with those who, in the Church, have the fullness of the means of salvation” (DJ 22).
There should be no doubt that the Church recognizes that followers of Islam have elements of truth. But while it is possible for them—as for all men—to be saved if they live up to the light God has given them, it cannot be said that Islam is a path of salvation or that Muslims do not need to become Christians.