And the same is true for America.
Why can’t the United States of America or Israel ever seem to win their ‘endless wars’? Because they have yet to fight the real enemy. Israel’s air strikes on Iran at least targeted the actual IRGC backers of Oct 7, while the U.S. has yet to deal with the Saudi, Qatari and Pakistani governments behind 9/11. But there is a hidden enemy that can’t just be droned.
What did Osama bin Laden and Hamas have in common? Both were part of the Muslim Brotherhood. Even more than Iran or any government, it’s the Muslim Brotherhood that binds together worldwide terrorist threats with political domestic pressure campaigns. The spectrum of Brotherhood influence combines together not only armed Jihadis, but Qatar’s Al Jazeera and other media influence operations, CAIR and other internal Democrat pressure groups and a majority of the mosques operating inside the United States. And that’s only the beginning.
Created in Egypt in the first half of the century with Nazi funding, the Brotherhood is a political Jihadist movement operating through both terrorist armies and front groups to seize power. The Muslim Brotherhood’s many arms are as comfortable setting off bombs on buses as they are meeting with members of Congress, preaching murder and pretending to be moderates.
The Brotherhood, which was strongest at universities in Egypt and parts of the Middle East, now also controls most elite campuses in America, and most Muslim organizations in America. In Israel, the Brotherhood maintains multiple front groups, including some that serve in Israel’s Knesset parliament, that run mosques across the country and effectively run all of Gaza.
After Oct 7, Hamas pulled back into its tunnels with its hostages and put up a limited fight even as its ‘civilian’ or as the media calls it ‘political arm’ continued running hospitals, the police, aid groups, local and regional media, which it used to fake a torrent of ‘atrocities’ by Israel.
Western diplomats, leaders and ‘experts’ have claimed that Israel won the war on Hamas, and should retreat and make some sort of deal, but as long as Hamas is, as the international community refers to them, the “de facto authorities’ on the ground, then nothing has been won.
After Israel reclaimed Gaza in the Six Day War, the Muslim Brotherhood, which had worked hand-in-glove with the Egyptian government to use Gaza as a base for crossing the border and carrying out massacres in Israel, pretended that it had changed and was now peaceful. It used its control over Gaza mosques and social service groups to indoctrinate the Muslim population into waging a Jihad even while the Israelis, like our governments, hoped that the Muslim Brotherhood had moderated and was willing to live and let live.
Then when the time was right, the mosques turned out to be full of weapons, the imams provided bombmaking instructions and the Brotherhood’s Mujama al-Islamiya, or the Islamic Center, became Hamas. When Hamas loses battles, it folds back and hides out in mosques.
That’s why all the talk of a ceasefire in which Hamas ‘disarms’ (that the Muslim Brotherhood terrorist group has rejected) would be meaningless because it would mean Hamas turning over its weapons to its own ‘Gaza police’ or some other political facade. And even if the weapons were turned over, as long as Hamas controls daily life in Gaza, it can organize, train, prepare, bring in more weapons and launch a new war any time it’s ready. Even if it takes years
America after 9/11 and Israel after Oct 7 focused on Jihad as ‘terrorism’ or a military conflict rather than a religious duty to kill and subjugate infidels imposed by the Koran on every devout Muslim. No matter how much money, how many soldiers or how many wars we fought against Jihadist forces, we never touched the core of their political organizations in local mosques.
Counterterrorism experts who knew better claimed that they could trick Muslims into moderating by recruiting mosques and Imams to teach them, which every Muslim child with even the lightest grounding in Islam knows better than to believe, that terrorism is against Islam.
The moderate Muslim gambit failed, but by then our counterterrorism ranks had been purged by Democrats and Republicans in thrall to Muslim Brotherhood front groups and no longer knew any better. The War on Terror became a ‘whack-a-mole’ game of taking out certain high-value Jihadists even as American cities were filled with mosques preaching Jihad against us.
The ‘experts’ pretended that the constant pace of Islamic terror attacks was the work of ‘lone wolves’ who, no matter how often they launched terror attacks and quoted the same verses, had just ‘misunderstood’ Islam and things would get better if we worked more closely with the Brotherhood’s mosques to teach the terrorists the true meaning of being moderate Muslims.
Beginning with Obama, the Israelis had negotiated a series of deals with Hamas which included, among other things, included giving the terror group economic rewards in exchange for quiet. The latest of these temporary agreements had been negotiated right before the Oct 7 attacks, and depended on the premise that the Muslim Brotherhood’s ‘civilian leadership’ was willing to moderate for economic reasons and would avoid further violence to get more money.
The catastrophic mistake led to the worst war in Israel’s modern history. And it won’t end until the Brotherhood is no longer able to operate in Israel’s territory. Just as our wars on terror won’t end until the Brotherhood and other Islamist groups are no longer able to operate in America.
Israelis are asking what the exit strategy for Gaza is. There isn’t one. Gaza is located next door to Israel. Oct 7 showed the folly of the ‘disengagement’ from Gaza and the forcible eviction of Jewish ‘settlers’ from their communities in Gaza. The only way to control territory is to physically control it. There are no shortcuts, no nation building or how to win hearts and minds with ‘three cups of tea’. Islamic terrorism does not emerge from anything except Islam. And while there are no ‘moderate’ forms of Islam, the Muslim Brotherhood is by far the most successful and dangerous Islamist operation in the world. Allowing it to exist is a suicide pact for any country.
That’s why even Arab Muslim countries have begun banning the Muslim Brotherhood, but America and Israel have yet to definitively ban and suppress all Brotherhood organizations.
To win in Gaza and eventually the West Bank, Israel has to detain and drive out every member of terrorist and terrorist adjacent groups. It’s not a new idea. In the early 90s, the Israelis deported most of the Hamas leadership to Jordan. The terrorists set up a tent camp demanding to be let back in. The UN, the Red Cross and the Bush and Clinton administrations rallied to advocate for Hamas and then demanded that Israel take Hamas leaders back. And Israel did.
The Oct 7 war should have already taught the Israelis that no matter how much they bend over backward to avoid harming ‘civilians’, they’ll still be charged with genocide. Likewise the Bush nation building efforts were smeared as a racist campaign to kill Muslims. America and Israel need to do the right thing to keep their people safe from the Brotherhood regardless of who screams about it, because going easy on the Jihadi ‘civilians’ has never worked anyway.
America and Israel should begin by outlawing the Brotherhood, all constituent groups, all groups that appeared in the documents seized in the post-9/11 raids and all groups whose leadership include Brotherhood members and past as well as present members of Brotherhood groups.
Membership in any Brotherhood group should be considered a basis for deportation for non-citizens and denaturalization followed by deportation if they’re citizens. America has these laws on the books, we’ve chosen not to use them. Israel certainly has the legal authority to do it, but a hostile radical leftist judiciary in both countries colluded to protect Brotherhood members (that is part of what the pre-Oct 7 leftist riots were about in Israel) and must be sidelined.
Israel must not just clean out terrorists in tunnels, but Brotherhood members in mosques, in aid groups, in hospitals, working for the UN and Al Jazeera, and the entire so-called ‘civilian’ government that controls Gaza. Those are the minimum conditions for any victory over Hamas, because the only way to defeat Hamas is to eliminate its Muslim Brotherhood parent group.
Unless they all go, the endless war will never end.
Billy says
Islam and its Muslims, the 50+ Islamic Countries, are the enemies of Israel, America, and the West as taught in Islam’s Quran(Quran 9:5, 29, 111, etc.). Islam’s Muslims are enemies of ALL Non-Muslims. EVERY Muslim prayer begins with Quran 1:1-, cursing Jews and Christians 15+ times a day. Demonic Allah in Quran 5:51 says, “O you who have believed[Muslims], DO NOT TAKE the Jews and the Nasara(Christians) as friends. They are friends to one another. And whoever among you takes them as friends, so surely he is of them. Surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.” See also Quran 2:63-65; 3:115; 4:144; 5:59-60, 82; 7:166. Moreover, Allah in Qur’an 8:39 says, “And engage in war with them[Non-Muslims] until there will not be sedition and the religion will be completely to Allah…”.
ISLAM IS FALSE, AHISTORICAL, AND DECEITFUL(Quran 3:54; 7:99; 8:30, etc.). There is NO MECCA, NO MUHAMMAD, and NO QURAN in the 7th century AD in Saudi Arabia despite the Muslim Standard Islamic Narrative(SIN) claims. Thus, Islam is a fallacious, factitious ideology imaginatively fabricated over time into the 21sth century, and there is NO PEACE with Islam and its Muslims. Allah’s cursed Islam, a Criminal-Terrorist Enterprise and a Murderous-Demonic Cult of Believers, Muslim Soldiers for Allah, continually fund, promote, and practice ideological subversion, propaganda, bigotry, discrimination, deceit, mass murder, intimidation, supremacy, segregation, hatred, incitement to violence, criminality, genocide, victimhood, censorship, and terrorism as taught in Islamic Law, Sharia, and in Islam’s Quran(Quran 8:60; 9:41, 88; 5:35, etc.).
Allah’s specious ideology in Qur’an 8:39 commands Muslims to fight Non-Muslims until they surrender to Muslim rule when it says, “And engage in war with them[Non-Muslims] until there will not be sedition and the religion will be completely to Allah…” Hence, Muslim actions should be legally challenged with a multi-faceted force of Western Laws like Muslims wield against Westerners via Tax Exempt Organizations, the Media and Hollywood, Foreign Funding, etc. because Islam violates and is incompatible with Western Laws(Quran 8:60; 9:5,29, 111; 47:4; 49:15; 60:4 etc.).
Like a Foreign Terrorist Organization(FTO) designated by the USA Secretary of State, Islam and its Muslims function as a MUSLIM TERRORIST ORGANIZATION(MTO) fighting against Non-Muslims to make Islam supreme and NOT A PEACEFUL religion under Western Law because Islam funds, teaches, and promotes Terrorist Criminal Organizations with Muslims as Terrorists for Allah(Quran 2:191; 4:89, 91; 9:5,29, 111; 49:15, etc.).
Allah’s Islam, a supremacist Antichrist Ideology, is using Western Freedoms and Laws against Non-Muslims to conquer Non-Muslims under Islamic Rule. Non-Muslims should legally designate Islam as a Muslim Terrorist Organization(MTO) where Mosques, Muslim Schools, Islamic Centers, Sharia Courts, and Muslim Organizations are banned because of their incitement of segregation and discrimination to fight back against ISLAMIZATION, Muslim subjugation, and tyrannical violence(Quran 4:65; 9:5,29,111; 60:4; 98:6-7, etc.).
Allah’s Muslims desire to make Islam supreme. Sahih Bukhari 3126 says, “… the Prophet said, He who fights so that Allah’s Word(ie. Islam) should be superior, fights for Allah’s Cause.” Allah, the Supreme Destroyer, in Quran 9:111 says, “Surely Allah has purchased from the believers[Muslims] their souls and their money so that they may have the garden[Heavenly Paradise]. They engage in war for the sake of Allah[ie. Allah’s Cause), so they kill and are killed…”. Allah teaches that Death By Jihad leads to Muslim Paradise. Allah in Qur’an 3:169 says, “And do not consider those who were killed for the sake of Allah as dead. Yet they are alive with their lord, receiving their provision.”
Under Islam and Islamic Law, Muslims have the Legal Right and the Quranic Duty to terrorize Non-Muslims because neglecting this QURANIC DUTY is a CRIME of Blasphemy, Unbelief, and Infidelity against tyrannical Allah. Jihad means warfare against Non-Muslims to ESTABLISH ISLAM’S RELIGION AS SUPREME(Quran 3:115, 151; 9:5, 29, 111; Muslim Law Manual: “Reliance of the Traveller”, o9.0, etc.).
More specifically, Islam, a terroristic-totalitarian way of life, is a Muslim Terrorist Ideology and Murderous, Criminal Enterprise of: incitement, intolerance, continuous war, discrimination, segregation, slavery, supremacy, genocide, polygamy, propaganda, deceit, hatred, sedition, terrorism, and violence against all Non-Muslims as taught in the Quran(Quran 2:191, 208,216; 4:65, 89,91, 95, 115; 5:14,64; 8:12,39,60, 74; 9:5,21,29,36, 41,49, 73,88, 111,123; 21:92; 47:4; 49:15; 60:4; 61:9-11; 62:6; 89:14; etc.).
somehistory says
The mozzie brotherhood is islime….all of it.
The “brotherhood” could be declared as violating RICO and all of its members in the U.S. arrested, tried, and if citizens, imprisoned. If not citizens, then deported as the terrorists they are.
And it is “terrorism.” Terrorism is the means by which a person or group wages war on a people to force a government to change policy. The mb in America has been waging war on the American people since at least the 90’s when they wrote the memorandum and the truck attack in NYC was committed.
War to change the government, not just the policy of the government.
cair is a loud spokes group for the mb and they helped put members in the government…tlaib, elmi, alias omar, ellison, and others. They have helped to put muzzies on court benches: and the student arm of the mb< msa work on campuses to foment trouble and cause changes in what is taught
Even if the law states that cair, msa, icna, mb, etc cannot be outlawed outright, any and all members can be charged under RICO.
cair would have gone down in defeat had bo not intervened for his pet bro's when he was first selected as a pretender to the presidency.
bo's ties to the mb….obvious from his insistence on their special treatment in Egypt in 09….should be thoroughly investigated and then he could be deported back to kenya.
mike says
The world Can’t Win Without Beating the Muslim Brotherhood
ploome says
Muslim Brotherhood IS islam
Gabriel Ben-Or says
I agree with all you said right up to the one word I looked for but failed to see: Quatar…
OLD GUY says
And you might ad Saudi Arabia.
rubiconcrest says
Nice work Daniel, especially this paragraph which is the heart of the issue, ‘America after 9/11 and Israel after Oct 7 focused on Jihad as ‘terrorism’ or a military conflict rather than a religious duty to kill and subjugate infidels imposed by the Koran on every devout Muslim. No matter how much money, how many soldiers or how many wars we fought against Jihadist forces, we never touched the core of their political organizations in local mosques.’
This was ‘the colossal mistake’ of Bush presidency. He had the opportunity, with the whole world watching, to give a lesson on Islam and drive a stake in it’s bloody heart. He failed and he’s still too stupid to realize it. Today we have thousands of mosques the majority of which are allied with the MB and we are overrun by a growing 5th column.
As a nation we are in a unique position. We don’t need ME oil we could start telling the truth and let the chips fall where they may. We’d be better off cutting off the problem now at the ankles than waiting another 20 years.
abu taleb says
Not MB, but Islam. MB is just an organization that follows Islam, but there are many other organization that have no relation with MB, Iran, Hezbollah and Houthi for example, they are Shia, so they should not have relation with MB. It is Islam that bind Hamas and Iran, not MB.
Even JihadWatch tries to whitewash Islam, and shift the blame to MB. So, I should not be surprised if the left morons are doing the same, right?
ploome says
exactly
Edward L. May says
Can’t win without an ethnic cleanse.
gravenimage says
Islam is not an ethnicity.
࿗Infidel࿘ says
Yeah, this is the hub of global jihad. Be it al Qaeda, Hamas, AQAP, CAIR, et al
Only problem: Trump had asked Netanyahu to consult him if he ever has any issues w/ Turkey. Despite the fact that through Syria, they are right at Israel’s northeastern borders
Also, does Israel then have a free hand in combating the muslim brotherhood in its strongholds like Egypt, Jordan and Syria?
aum says
You cannot come up with a solution until you define the problem.
Great Work Daniel.
Gunter Deleyn says
The big problem is the education/indoctrination in their schools from a very young age. Even kindergarten aged. The Palestinian schools are almost all named after so called martyrs (suicide bombers) and they are examples for kids from the age of 4-5 old. They are encouraged to become martyrs themselves, and join Allah in heaven. For example you have a school in Gaza named after Dalal Mughrabi. She blew up a bus in 1978 and killed 38 Israelis including 13 children. The girls in that school are encouraged to follow her example. To my shame, that particular school is sponsored by Belgium, my country.
Paul says
Nothing will help. If you get them all, and you won’t. The ideas will just float back in. Israel does not have a plan that wants to win, let alone to try to implement it.
The plan now is to basically leave Gaza back to the Palestinians eventually and pull out and pray moderate Islam magically appears.
Winston 101 says
Even after the hideous meat grinder experience of WWI, the West had to recognize that the Axis powers didn’t leave them a choice about entering WWII. The West had to figure out how to defeat the Axis totalitarians.
After the end of WWII the West had to learn how to defeat the Communist totalitarians in a Cold War that turned hot in Viet Nam etc. It ended with the collapse of the Soviet Union and the victory of the West over the communist totalitarians.
Islam is a totalitarian form of government that includes a religion. It wants to rule over believers and nonbelievers alike. Islam is not giving the West a choice in whether we engage in this war. Their book, the Quran, declared war on the West 1400 years ago. With the infusion of wealth, ironically brought about by the oil needs of the West, Islam has been transfused with a level of power they never previously possessed.
But here we are. Will Islam leave us alone? Ask the Druze in Syria, the Christians in West Africa, the Hindus in India. The West is facing an age old, aggressive, totalitarian system hell bent on world domination.
This is why the U S needs to support Israel. Israel is part of the West and it’s located in the belly of the beast. Israel is an excellent ally. Some other countries, like Poland and Hungary, clearly recognize the war. Hopefully, others are becoming dimly aware.
Recognizing the war declared on us by Islamic totalitarianism, cloaked as a religion, and a religion of peace no less, would naturally lead to banning of all things Islamic in the West, Muslim Brotherhood et al.
But first, you would have to recognize the reality of Islamic aggressive totalitarianism.
gravenimage says
+1
Gidon says
I think that you have laid out an excellent blueprint that would enable the defeat of our nemesis and the restoration of western civilization to it’s rightful place at the uncontested TOP of the world order. It’;s them or us. We should choose US!!
gravenimage says
Israel Can’t Win Without Beating the Muslim Brotherhood
………………………………………..
Good analysis from Daniel Greenfield.