Maj.-Gen.Eyal Zamiar and his associates, the Jerusalem Post has learned, want the war in Gaza to end within two to three weeks. Their thinking is as follows: first, in such an arrangement all of the living hostages, not just a few as is currently being discussed, would come home, ending the stress and divisions in Israel society over their return; second, there are so few Hamas targets left to hit in Gaza, so that the law of diminishing returns has set in; three, Israel has, alas, been losing the battle of public opinion, as videos of killed or wounded children in Gaza, and the endless rubble, are shown on television, while Hamas-provided numbers on casualties in Gaza, and on the makeup of those casualties (women and children seem remarkably to predominate) are uncritically accepted by the media. Israel is also being accused of deliberately killing aid seekers, though it is Hamas that is doing the killing in order to make sure that the GHF distribution of aid will fail; the IDF fires warning shots at some Gazans, but only when they ignore commands not to approach too closely to those guarding the aid; the Israelis have also been accused by Hamas of poisoning — with expensive oxycodone! — the food the GHF hands out. Why the Israelis would wish to sabotage their own delivery of aid by poisoning recipients so that others will stay away is not made clear; it is, of course, complete nonsense.
The IDF wants to return some of its hundreds of thousands of reservists to civilian life, where their absence from work has had economic consequences. It also wants to concentrate, after 21 months of war in Gaza, on its other fronts. With Iran, it may renew its strikes on the Islamic Republic if it shows any signs of trying to restart either its nuclear program or its ballistic missile program. The IDF still has to bomb the Houthis into submission, as they have shown themselves to be remarkably resilient, and continue to lob missiles and drones towards Israel. In Lebanon, the IDF has built five outposts in southern Lebanon that it intends to hold onto, and has been attacking Hezbollah fighters who have not pulled out of southern Lebanon, as they had agreed to do. Israel wants to so weaken Hezbollah that the Lebanese National Army can take over and finish the job, pushing to disarm Hezbollah throughout Lebanon and to turn it into a purely political movement. Israel intends to hold onto the territory on the Syrian side of Golan it took over just after Assad’s fall, and it has also seized all of Mt. Hermon, which looms over Damascus; the IDF is not about to relinquish control of those commanding heights. It also has to worry about Turkish forces in northern Syria, where Ankara has seized control of Syrian territory in order to keep watch on the restive Kurds in Syria, for fear that their separatist dreams might also inspire Kurds in Turkey to make common cause with them. So there’s a lot for the IDF to worry about, and getting out of Gaza would free up many tens of thousands of troops for deployment elsewhere.
More on the security establishment’s hope to end the Gaza war soon can be found here: “Israel’s security elite want end of Gaza war in two-three weeks, sources tell ‘Post’ – analysis,” by Yonah Jeremy Bob, Jerusalem Post, July 3, 2025:
With senior sources telling The Jerusalem Post the defense establishment wants the war to end within two to three weeks, and US President Donald Trump pushing for a potential end even sooner, might the current dizzying Middle East conflict of 20 months finally come to an end?
Or will continued opposition from Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir once again extend the war?
Alternatively, might Israel and Hamas reach a third temporary ceasefire, which only freezes hostilities for two months or longer, but with the sides eventually resuming the conflict later in 2025 or early 2026?
In addressing the issue, the first question is: Why might the war finally end this time, when earlier negotiations – November 2023 (first ceasefire), May 2024 (close to a deal), August 2024 (close to a deal), and this March (second ceasefire) – did not end it?
While Israel may also get some improved terms in negotiations with Hamas, the most important elements here are: IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Eyal Zamir, Trump, and the 12-day Iran war.
Zamir is in a completely different position than his predecessor, Herzi Halevi, who had major achievements during the war, but also had the albatross of the October 7 massacre permanently stained on his name. He was never trusted by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, because he was appointed while Netanyahu was out of office….
Unlike his predecessor, Herzl Halevi, Eyal Zamir was not tainted by the October 7 failure. Herzl resigned because it was widely felt that he had, along with some others, failed to foresee, or prevent, the Hamas atrocities carried out that day. General Zamir came into office having played no part in the October 7 debacle.
During General Zamir’s short tenure in office as chief of the general staff, the results have been spectacular. The IDF has seized far more of Gaza in a few months than had been seized by the IDF in the 18 previous months when Halevi was still in charge. And then in twelve days, the IDF hammered Iran, destroying a dozen nuclear sites and damaging three more — at Natanz, Fordow, and Isfahan —- after which the American bunker-busters bombs delivered what appears to have been the coup de grâce of all three. The latest judgement, from both the CIA and the Israelis, is that Iran’s nuclear program has been set back by several years.
Zamir is untouched, as Halevi was not, by the October 7 debacle, and furthermore, he has been so successful militarily, both in subduing Hamas and cornering it in 25% of the Gazan territory, and in dealing a colossal blow to Iran, that he is in a position to push Netanyahu to accept his, Zamir’s, view of the IDF’s continued war in Gaza. It is General Eyal Zamir who is now unassailable, and if Netanyahu crosses him — by, say, ordering him to continue fighting in Gaza when Zamir thinks it now makes more sense to stop — he will do so at his own political peril. Besides, if all of the hostages will now be returned in a ceasefire agreement, Netanyahu can take the credit.
And once out of Gaza, the IDF can concentrate on the following: first, holding onto the territory it has seized from Syria on the Golan and on Mount Hermon, which is now completely in Israeli hands, while hoping to persuade Al-Sharaa that Israel will be a useful counterweight to Turkey, which has seized territory, in order to control the Kurds in Syria; second, keeping the five outposts it has built in southern Lebanon to prevent Hezbollah from remaining anywhere south of the Litani River; third, keeping up military pressure on the Islamic Republic — including repeated bombings of Iranian nuclear sites, perhaps even with bunker-buster bombs and B-2 bombers that the Americans might now be willing to lend to Israel, should Tehran show any signs of restarting its nuclear program.
commonsense says
Kudos to Hugh Fitzgerald, who provides a lucid explanation as to why Israel may be willing to agree to what seemed (to me) to be an ill-advised hudna with Hamas. I suspect this analysis will be extremely difficult to find elsewhere, except perhaps in Israel.
࿗Infidel࿘ says
Problem is that Hamas has both Israel and the US over a barrel. Simple reason: the hostages are far more valuable to Israel (and the US), than say Hamas prisoners in Israeli jails would be to Hamas. And Hamas can’t release them, b’cos they lose all leverage once all the living hostages are back in Israel. Icing on the cake for Hamas – even the dead hostages are too valuable to Israel. A number of other countries would have, in such a scenario, decided, once all living hostages were released, to just massacre what was left of Hamas, and look for the cadavers later
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usI_jqcH4jE
Maybe those Mossad ops that they did so well in Iran – maybe they should try doing some of that in Gaza to rescue the hostages. Oh, and not tell us how they did it once it’s done
gravenimage says
IDF Wants to End Gaza War Within 2-3 Weeks
……………………………………………
I just hope Israel can rescue the rest of the living hostages.
I would love to see Hamas destroyed. but at least it has been significantly weakened.
Joe1 says
This might be cruel, but I think it would be better to let a little of Hamas continue. Gaza is not Germany; rather, Gaza is united by Islam. If Hamas was destroyed, then it would be, “Meet the new boss, just like the old boss”. It is better to weaken Hamas to the point that it has rivals, and then let the Muslims fight it out, since war seems to be their favorite hobby.
Kimberly says
I’ve noticed that. Islam doesn’t mean peace it means submission.
Alex Lund says
Sorry, but thats just pure hopium.
The IDF made a lot of mistakes in handling the situation.
They give and give and give and get nearly nothing in return.
And they wont get peace that way.
No, the only way to get what you want is STRENGTH, pure STRENGTH and the willpower to see it through.
The hostages will never be released, they are to much worth for the palestinians then to release them.
Thats what the IDF should have done after the attack:
Total blockade of the Gaza strip. Nothing in or out. And total means total! As many jammers as needed to isolate the Gaza from the outside world.
Declare, that the blockade will only be lifted after a) all hostages are back, b) those that kidnapped them / hurt them / killed them are turned over and c) all – and that means really ALL) Hamas members turn themselves over to the IDF.
Meanwhile move into the Gaza and take every Palestinian you can capture as counter-hostages. Put them in camps. One for males and the other for females.
Treat them nearly exactly (except rape or other inhuman things) like the hostages, water and food only every third day, remove their burquas and other clothing except underwear.
And then tell the Palestinians that the hostages better survive, because the survival of the counter-hostages depends on it.
OLD GUY says
Problem if Hamas goes away another Islamic group will form and repeat. If Hamas is allowed to survive it will also repeat once it strengthens. As long as Islamic countries are strong financially and politically Israel and the west will continue to be attacked. It is simple Islam wants to rule the world.
࿗Infidel࿘ says
Better solution would be Trump’s idea of relocating all Gazans to other Arab countries, such as Libya, and let the Israelis move in & clean up the place. Then new waterfront properties can be developed, and non-muslims from other countries in the region moved in – Syrian Christians, Iraqi Christians, Yazidis, & so on
Winston 101 says
Infidel,
I’ve learned to sit with Trumps ideas for a moment before deciding on their validity. Ever since he came down the escalator and said such shocking things – that all proved to be true! He was just sayings true things in a culture saturated with untruths passed off as true by the sources of information at the time.
So his ideas about repopulating the Mediterranean coast of “Palestine” bear serious consideration.
My question is: Who would form the labor force? Obviously, no one who could be a threat to the security of the project. It would be a plumb jihadi target for suicide bombers and sabotage.
Seems like the Saudis and UAE have large project experience and security implementation.
Any ideas?
Troybeam says
End the war, the war could have ended sooner if Israeli’s had just done the job right in the first place.
Bomb the shit out of Gaza, no notices on what they intended and finally no humanitarian supplies because it’s only aiding and abetting those soldiers they are fighting.
Israel made many mistakes and it drew this out longer than needed and that was a huge mistake.