Get Muhammad: A Critical Biographyhere. Get Did Muhammad Exist?here.
Comments
Walter Sieruksays
On this top subject of “Mahammad had ever really existed or not”, is very interesting.
Nevertheless, from on aspect ,as in viewing this from a Bible based Christian perspective , the most important thing is that the religion of Islam does exist and it’s doing much spiritual harm by leading millions of people astray and straight in the hell , because the false doctrines of Islam are very dangerous to the human soul , if the person believes in the bogus teachings of Islam.
Especially regarding Islam’s denial that Jesus id God. To put this explain this in another way ,in more detail. Islam is in major a Biblical doctrinal error concerning nature of Jesus and is therefore a false religion.
The subject of great importance is that Jesus is God and therefore Islam is in major Biblical doctrinal error concerning nature of Jesus and is therefore a false religion.
In the Old Testament of Isaiah in 45:22,23.” starting at the second sentence it reads ” I am God and there is no other…That to Me every knee shall bow . Every tongue shall taken an oath. He shall say ‘Surely in the Lord I have righteousness and strength…” [N.K.J.V.]
Moving on to the New Testament and comparing those above Isaiah verse with Philippians 2:10,11 the reader is informed that “That at the name of Jesus every shall bow , of those in heaven and of those on the under the earth and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord to the glory God the Father.”
So in those Old Testament reveal that to God “every knee shall bow..” and likewise those New Testament verses reveal that to Jesus “every knee shall bow…” This clearly shows that Jesus is God.
In Psalm 89:8,9. it reads “O Lord of host, Who is mighty like you , O Lord ? … You rule the raging of the sea ; when it’s waves rise you still them.” In Matthew 8:23-27 a terrible sea storm occurred and then rebuked the winds and the sea, and there was a great clam. So the men marveled, saying ‘Who can this be , that even the winds and the sea obey him. ” By comparing what happened with those verses from that just quoted Psalm, the answer to the question asked by the disciples of Jesus is that He is God.
Furthermore the Bible in First Kings 8:39 teaches that “Only God Knows that thoughts of men” in the Gospel of Mark 2: 8 reveals that Jesus knows the thoughts of men.”
In conclusion the Bible does reveal to that Jesus is God and that exposes Islam’s false teaching about Jesus and therefore Islam is a false religion of demonic darkness.
As Isaiah 8:20 reads ” To the law and to the Testimony ! If they do not speak according to the word, it is because there is no light in them.”
In conclusion, it may be truly said that Jesus is not religion. He is far better than religion, which includes Islam.
The Bible gives its reader very important information about what Jesus did for every person by being the Supreme Ransom for the sinner by taking his or her place on the cross on behalf of that human being.
In other words, Jesus made Himself Absolute Sacrifice for sinners in place of each one of them.
For God the Father gave Jesus, the, John 3:16, for a person who is willing to accept His work, he Total and Complete Atoning Sacrifice, for him or her.
As the Bible informs its reader, “For He made Him who knew no sin for us, to be sin for us that we might become the righteousness of God in Him.” Second Corinthians 5:21.
Mikesays
Walter: I appreciate your comments, but I don’t think it’s fair to imply that Judaism is a false religion, simply because it denies that Jesus is God.
Both Judaism and Christianity place a strong emphasis on the Two Chief Commandments, and especially on the Golden Rule Commandment: “You shall love your neighbour as yourself.”
Islam seems to lack an explicit Golden Rule, though there are many Muslims who follow this principle nonetheless.
In terms of Jewish views of Jesus, there are quite a diversity of perspectives. However, Jews would agree that Jesus isn’t God, and that He isn’tvthe Messiah. Moreover, they might also assert that He wasn’t a prophet (or at least, not a prophet to the Jewish people).
Walter Sieruksays
I’m not against Judaism . after it wasn’t the followers of Judaism who engaged i n those murderous jihadist attacks on September 11, 2001 It was follower of Islam who did it, nearly 23 years ago.
In addition, since those other murderous jihad Islamic terrorists by the jihadist of Hamas, on October 7th 2023 I’ve gone out of my way to purchases products made in Israel, ,though internet. What more those Hamas 10/7/23 mass murder jihad attacks was a catalyst for me to travel to Israel this coming March. I’m now all “booked up ” and ready to go. All I need now in anew camera.
Walter Sieruksays
About the controversy about if Muhammad really did exist an person in history or is he just a character in a myth of a bogus Islamic “history” isn’t as of as that much importance as that of the subject of Islam’s denial that Jesus is God.
For many false religions, including Islam, deny that Jesus is God. In spite of that denial the Bible clearly reveals that Jesus is God. As found in John 1 ;1-5. 20:28. Romans 9:5.
Furthermore, by comparing John 5:22 with Romans 14:12. a person can see the Jesus is God. Second Peter 1:.1. First John 5:20.Likewise by comparing the Old and New Testament books together that Jesus is God may be discovered , As by comparing Psalm 89:8,9 with Matthew 8:23-27. Also in comparing Isaiah 46:22,23 with Philippians 2: 5-11 shows Jesus to be God.
The Bible instructs that the way for a person to discover if a doctrine or teaching is true or false to compare it to what is already written in the scripture. So if that teaching or doctrine is in contradiction what is in the Word of God, the Bible then that doctrine or teaching is false.
As Isaiah 8:20 reads “To the law and to the testimony! If they do not speak according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.”
[N.K.J.V.]
InfidelLoversays
I am more interested to know if anyone has heard from Hatun Tash.
Her website does not appear to be updated since 2021.
A journalist at the Spectator said he had spoked to her before the trial of man who wished to harm her. That trial was in May 2024. Police in the UK say they do not regard her as missing. But none of her friends like Jay Smith have seen her, as far as I know.
I do not conclusively know she is alive and well.
gravenimagesays
I believe that the above is a recent interview with Hatun Tash, so she is all right.
࿗Infidel࿘says
She is fine: these interviews/conversations were from yesterday, when she talked to Robert about this, as well as going thru the qur’an
gravenimagesays
Video: Did Muhammad Exist? Hatun Tash and Robert Spencer Answer Farid
……………………………………..
Not something you are even allowed to ask under Islam. But Christians. Jews, Buddhists, and Hindus can safely ask about the historical existance of even their most sacred figures–as can anyone else.
Walter R. Schumm, Ph.D., COL (USA, Ret)says
If Muhammad existed, he was probably born in Petra rather than Mecca, see Dan Gibson’s book: Let the Stones Speak (2023).
Hudders.says
Excellent video once again.
Please keep them coming. They are getting viewed much more by many more lately.
Hallelujah!
Judaism is a false religion. If we don’t have Jesus, we have nothing. Jesus said “you believe in God, believe also in Me”. Jesus also said “I am the Way, the Truth & the Life, no one comes to the Father, except thru Me. If only God could make the Jews read the WHOLE Bible, they would see that their Messiah has already come!!! There’s 7 years of great tribulation coming to Jews who are NOT Messianic Jews. That’s where ‘JESUS SAVES’ comes in. Jesus is God’s only Son, sent from heaven to save His people from our sins. & all you have to do is repent, confess your sins as you call upon the Lord to forgive you for all ur sin. Do it today, tomorrow may be TOO LATE.
Edward Amos Brandweinsays
Sorry but that’s your opinion, not a universal truth
Judaism is as truthful a religion as Christianity
gravenimagesays
+1
Edward Amos Brandweinsays
False assumption and belief
somehistorysays
The Bible makes clear that Jehovah God was with the Israelites and He gave them the Law, it was their “tutor leading to the Christ.” All of the faithful Jews from day one were looking for the Messiah. Many verses written by various Jews told the people of Israel things for which to look and expect so they would know Christ when He appeared. There are at least 300 Scriptures about Jesus…from where and to whom He would be born, all the way to His sacrificial death and Resurrection.
Jesus was a Jew, He and His family abided by the Law of Moses until He declared that the Law was fulfilled. The Law was not *false* and it was all fulfilled in Jesus Christ.
Furthermore, Jesus, Who told us of the “great tribulation,” never put a number of years for it in His prophecy. We cannot know how long it will be, but He did say, “The days will be cut short, or no flesh will be saved.”
Pray Hardsays
“mohammed” probably only existed as a mythical construct of the typical arabic male of that time and place.
gravenimagesays
It’s even worse than this, Pray Hard. The dark ages Arab was a pretty barbaric fellow–but not barbaric enough for Islam. Islam is full of admonishments that Arabs are not vicious *enougn* to follow Islam properly, and urgings to be more brutal. Ugly stuff.
gravenimagesays
Excellent scholarship from Robert Spencer showing how late this Islamic stuff actually was.
My faviorite, though, is the claim from Farid that there is supposed proof that “Prophet” Muhammed ate chicken, while there is no proof that Jesus is God. Now, I get it–the idea is that we supposedly have proof of even minor points about Muhammed, but not even major issues regarding the Jesus of the Gospels. But this is still hilarious–who cares whether Muhammed–or Jesus–ate chicken or not? This has no real message for their followers one way or the other.
But as Hatun Tash mentions, we *also* know that Mughammed is reported beating his wives and mass murdering unbelievers–rather more salient, no?
TIJERANDYtsays
Mohammad was illiterate…he wrote NOTHING. Jesus’s words were documented by the Apostles, including Matthew. In real time. Whether Mohammad lived or not is irrelevant…He is/was a MYTH. The people who follow him today prove he was a rapist, murderer, mutilator, perpetrator of GENOCIDE. When will these people wake up? 1,400 years of Evil ..a Cancer on Civilization.
somehistorysays
The fact that Jesus Christ lived, taught the people, had disciples, was hated, etc. has been documented, not just by the Bible writers, but by at least 20 secular sources. Jesus lived and continues to live.
If the mass murderer, slave-trading thief, a sack of feculent stink, who raped children and lied so others would obey his every word, ever lived, he has been worm debris….dirt…for centuries; and unable to know, do or hear anything.
Those who follow and worship him, prove how evil he was….if he lived. And if he didn’t, the one who wrote the book of demon filth, was just as evil as the fake prophet was written to be.
Discover more from
Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.
Walter Sieruk says
On this top subject of “Mahammad had ever really existed or not”, is very interesting.
Nevertheless, from on aspect ,as in viewing this from a Bible based Christian perspective , the most important thing is that the religion of Islam does exist and it’s doing much spiritual harm by leading millions of people astray and straight in the hell , because the false doctrines of Islam are very dangerous to the human soul , if the person believes in the bogus teachings of Islam.
Especially regarding Islam’s denial that Jesus id God. To put this explain this in another way ,in more detail. Islam is in major a Biblical doctrinal error concerning nature of Jesus and is therefore a false religion.
The subject of great importance is that Jesus is God and therefore Islam is in major Biblical doctrinal error concerning nature of Jesus and is therefore a false religion.
In the Old Testament of Isaiah in 45:22,23.” starting at the second sentence it reads ” I am God and there is no other…That to Me every knee shall bow . Every tongue shall taken an oath. He shall say ‘Surely in the Lord I have righteousness and strength…” [N.K.J.V.]
Moving on to the New Testament and comparing those above Isaiah verse with Philippians 2:10,11 the reader is informed that “That at the name of Jesus every shall bow , of those in heaven and of those on the under the earth and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord to the glory God the Father.”
So in those Old Testament reveal that to God “every knee shall bow..” and likewise those New Testament verses reveal that to Jesus “every knee shall bow…” This clearly shows that Jesus is God.
In Psalm 89:8,9. it reads “O Lord of host, Who is mighty like you , O Lord ? … You rule the raging of the sea ; when it’s waves rise you still them.” In Matthew 8:23-27 a terrible sea storm occurred and then rebuked the winds and the sea, and there was a great clam. So the men marveled, saying ‘Who can this be , that even the winds and the sea obey him. ” By comparing what happened with those verses from that just quoted Psalm, the answer to the question asked by the disciples of Jesus is that He is God.
Furthermore the Bible in First Kings 8:39 teaches that “Only God Knows that thoughts of men” in the Gospel of Mark 2: 8 reveals that Jesus knows the thoughts of men.”
In conclusion the Bible does reveal to that Jesus is God and that exposes Islam’s false teaching about Jesus and therefore Islam is a false religion of demonic darkness.
As Isaiah 8:20 reads ” To the law and to the Testimony ! If they do not speak according to the word, it is because there is no light in them.”
In conclusion, it may be truly said that Jesus is not religion. He is far better than religion, which includes Islam.
The Bible gives its reader very important information about what Jesus did for every person by being the Supreme Ransom for the sinner by taking his or her place on the cross on behalf of that human being.
In other words, Jesus made Himself Absolute Sacrifice for sinners in place of each one of them.
For God the Father gave Jesus, the, John 3:16, for a person who is willing to accept His work, he Total and Complete Atoning Sacrifice, for him or her.
As the Bible informs its reader, “For He made Him who knew no sin for us, to be sin for us that we might become the righteousness of God in Him.” Second Corinthians 5:21.
Mike says
Walter: I appreciate your comments, but I don’t think it’s fair to imply that Judaism is a false religion, simply because it denies that Jesus is God.
Both Judaism and Christianity place a strong emphasis on the Two Chief Commandments, and especially on the Golden Rule Commandment: “You shall love your neighbour as yourself.”
Islam seems to lack an explicit Golden Rule, though there are many Muslims who follow this principle nonetheless.
In terms of Jewish views of Jesus, there are quite a diversity of perspectives. However, Jews would agree that Jesus isn’t God, and that He isn’tvthe Messiah. Moreover, they might also assert that He wasn’t a prophet (or at least, not a prophet to the Jewish people).
Walter Sieruk says
I’m not against Judaism . after it wasn’t the followers of Judaism who engaged i n those murderous jihadist attacks on September 11, 2001 It was follower of Islam who did it, nearly 23 years ago.
In addition, since those other murderous jihad Islamic terrorists by the jihadist of Hamas, on October 7th 2023 I’ve gone out of my way to purchases products made in Israel, ,though internet. What more those Hamas 10/7/23 mass murder jihad attacks was a catalyst for me to travel to Israel this coming March. I’m now all “booked up ” and ready to go. All I need now in anew camera.
Walter Sieruk says
About the controversy about if Muhammad really did exist an person in history or is he just a character in a myth of a bogus Islamic “history” isn’t as of as that much importance as that of the subject of Islam’s denial that Jesus is God.
For many false religions, including Islam, deny that Jesus is God. In spite of that denial the Bible clearly reveals that Jesus is God. As found in John 1 ;1-5. 20:28. Romans 9:5.
Furthermore, by comparing John 5:22 with Romans 14:12. a person can see the Jesus is God. Second Peter 1:.1. First John 5:20.Likewise by comparing the Old and New Testament books together that Jesus is God may be discovered , As by comparing Psalm 89:8,9 with Matthew 8:23-27. Also in comparing Isaiah 46:22,23 with Philippians 2: 5-11 shows Jesus to be God.
The Bible instructs that the way for a person to discover if a doctrine or teaching is true or false to compare it to what is already written in the scripture. So if that teaching or doctrine is in contradiction what is in the Word of God, the Bible then that doctrine or teaching is false.
As Isaiah 8:20 reads “To the law and to the testimony! If they do not speak according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.”
[N.K.J.V.]
InfidelLover says
I am more interested to know if anyone has heard from Hatun Tash.
Her website does not appear to be updated since 2021.
A journalist at the Spectator said he had spoked to her before the trial of man who wished to harm her. That trial was in May 2024. Police in the UK say they do not regard her as missing. But none of her friends like Jay Smith have seen her, as far as I know.
I do not conclusively know she is alive and well.
gravenimage says
I believe that the above is a recent interview with Hatun Tash, so she is all right.
࿗Infidel࿘ says
She is fine: these interviews/conversations were from yesterday, when she talked to Robert about this, as well as going thru the qur’an
gravenimage says
Video: Did Muhammad Exist? Hatun Tash and Robert Spencer Answer Farid
……………………………………..
Not something you are even allowed to ask under Islam. But Christians. Jews, Buddhists, and Hindus can safely ask about the historical existance of even their most sacred figures–as can anyone else.
Walter R. Schumm, Ph.D., COL (USA, Ret) says
If Muhammad existed, he was probably born in Petra rather than Mecca, see Dan Gibson’s book: Let the Stones Speak (2023).
Hudders. says
Excellent video once again.
Please keep them coming. They are getting viewed much more by many more lately.
Hallelujah!
Donna says
Without lies Islam dies!! 🤣 LMAO
that’s awesome
Jody says
Judaism is a false religion. If we don’t have Jesus, we have nothing. Jesus said “you believe in God, believe also in Me”. Jesus also said “I am the Way, the Truth & the Life, no one comes to the Father, except thru Me. If only God could make the Jews read the WHOLE Bible, they would see that their Messiah has already come!!! There’s 7 years of great tribulation coming to Jews who are NOT Messianic Jews. That’s where ‘JESUS SAVES’ comes in. Jesus is God’s only Son, sent from heaven to save His people from our sins. & all you have to do is repent, confess your sins as you call upon the Lord to forgive you for all ur sin. Do it today, tomorrow may be TOO LATE.
Edward Amos Brandwein says
Sorry but that’s your opinion, not a universal truth
Judaism is as truthful a religion as Christianity
gravenimage says
+1
Edward Amos Brandwein says
False assumption and belief
somehistory says
The Bible makes clear that Jehovah God was with the Israelites and He gave them the Law, it was their “tutor leading to the Christ.” All of the faithful Jews from day one were looking for the Messiah. Many verses written by various Jews told the people of Israel things for which to look and expect so they would know Christ when He appeared. There are at least 300 Scriptures about Jesus…from where and to whom He would be born, all the way to His sacrificial death and Resurrection.
Jesus was a Jew, He and His family abided by the Law of Moses until He declared that the Law was fulfilled. The Law was not *false* and it was all fulfilled in Jesus Christ.
Furthermore, Jesus, Who told us of the “great tribulation,” never put a number of years for it in His prophecy. We cannot know how long it will be, but He did say, “The days will be cut short, or no flesh will be saved.”
Pray Hard says
“mohammed” probably only existed as a mythical construct of the typical arabic male of that time and place.
gravenimage says
It’s even worse than this, Pray Hard. The dark ages Arab was a pretty barbaric fellow–but not barbaric enough for Islam. Islam is full of admonishments that Arabs are not vicious *enougn* to follow Islam properly, and urgings to be more brutal. Ugly stuff.
gravenimage says
Excellent scholarship from Robert Spencer showing how late this Islamic stuff actually was.
My faviorite, though, is the claim from Farid that there is supposed proof that “Prophet” Muhammed ate chicken, while there is no proof that Jesus is God. Now, I get it–the idea is that we supposedly have proof of even minor points about Muhammed, but not even major issues regarding the Jesus of the Gospels. But this is still hilarious–who cares whether Muhammed–or Jesus–ate chicken or not? This has no real message for their followers one way or the other.
But as Hatun Tash mentions, we *also* know that Mughammed is reported beating his wives and mass murdering unbelievers–rather more salient, no?
TIJERANDYt says
Mohammad was illiterate…he wrote NOTHING. Jesus’s words were documented by the Apostles, including Matthew. In real time. Whether Mohammad lived or not is irrelevant…He is/was a MYTH. The people who follow him today prove he was a rapist, murderer, mutilator, perpetrator of GENOCIDE. When will these people wake up? 1,400 years of Evil ..a Cancer on Civilization.
somehistory says
The fact that Jesus Christ lived, taught the people, had disciples, was hated, etc. has been documented, not just by the Bible writers, but by at least 20 secular sources. Jesus lived and continues to live.
If the mass murderer, slave-trading thief, a sack of feculent stink, who raped children and lied so others would obey his every word, ever lived, he has been worm debris….dirt…for centuries; and unable to know, do or hear anything.
Those who follow and worship him, prove how evil he was….if he lived. And if he didn’t, the one who wrote the book of demon filth, was just as evil as the fake prophet was written to be.