Here in microcosm is the difference between Islamic culture and Judeo-Christian culture. If a Protestant church or some other organization held a content on Bible memorization, the losers and those who made errors would not be punished. But in an Islamic context, this surprises no one. This is a glimpse into the future of the West.
“Egyptian Lawmaker Calls for Measures against Qaris Who Recite Quran Erroneously,” International Quran News Agency, August 31, 2024 (thanks to The Religion of Peace):
IQNA – A member of parliament in Egypt said the law should be strictly enforced against those who recite the Quran incorrectly.
Khalid Tantawi urged the country’s Association of Quran Reciters and Memorizers to introduce new and decisive regulations to prevent errors in recitation, Youm7 website reported.
He appreciated the efforts made by the head of the association, Mohamed Salih Rashad, in this regard but expressed regret over the repetition of mistakes by qaris while reciting Quran.
Tantawi called on Rashad to punish all of those who make such mistakes and ban their recitation in different media outlets….
SC says
I say punish them and those that are not better than them. Sit the uneducated ones on on a gigaton nuke in the center of Cairo and blast them to allah to learn to be educated.
Frank Lord says
Islam is perpetuated by using young virgin women as reward in the form of a sexual slavery arranged marriages to middle aged Muslim men who bang on about how great their imaginary god is ..
There are no ghosts , no devils and no gods . Just horny old men ..
Sadly these greedy old men, sow the seeds of radicalism and terrorism to keep things as they are .. islamic terrorism and religious bigotry is inspired by the rantings of these old men hoping to get an arranged marriage.. old men marrying young women is totally wrong especially when these old perverts are stealing the young brides to be of young Muslim men who are left without a wife frustrated and angry .. very angry
I’ve interacted with a Muslim woman you’d call an influencer .. She started of very frosty and angry but after a duel of words, she I believe, realised that my comment actually overlaps with her own sense of injustice that she feels on behalf of young Muslims women who have been victims of arranged marriages ..
This is not racist ..
This an attempt to re – educate young Muslims ..
To stop the cycle of hatred for us, non Muslims, that enimates from their community . To stop the anger that young Muslim men and Women feel towards us .. An anger that has been instigated and perpetrated by middle aged men as a cover story for their path following a slave trader and slave taker who lived 1500 years ago ! Mohamed set into motion a system, whereby middle aged men can buy a young virgin to sexually abuse and enslave, for an affordable amount of money paid to the so called clerics, on the condition that the buyer sings praises to the system that enslaves these young women .. this cycle of hatred and anger that enslaves young women must be broken .. So much misery has been unleashed by this set of rules ..
FYI says
What about us infidels{“the worst of created beings” koran 98:6 }who..
1]like to spell Holey Kooooran incorrectly
2}Point out all the scientific,historical,theological and logical errors in the Holey koooooanr like allah’s laughable claim that christians worship THREE gods in koran 5:116 which is not very omniscient of allah who claims to be the”knower if ALL things” koran 2:29 is it?If allah really was the”knower of all things” allah would know that he has completley misunderstood Christian Theology
As for allah’s well known scientific errors we’d be here all week.
muslims might call it cherry-picking;I call it cheery picking.Cheerfully exposing the fraud that is islam.A false prophet{even by his own admisson}a fraud of a holey book and a god who is clearly a human impersonator of the Biblical/Torah God who suffers from an amazing and provable lack of omniscience
3:}Reguate this..
allahuwallahuwackabackadoodlebug
Taffy says
You forgot Allah’s Pegasus where he flew all the way to the Temple Mount on his flying horse powered by two Pratt and Whitney F135 engines cranking out 40.000 l s of thrust a piece.
abu taleb says
There are different Quran versions in the Middle East alone, not to mention in other regions (old Qurans in Islamic schools in my country are different too). So, will the owner and reader of different version Quran be punished too?
Muslims can bury their heads in sand just like the western governments on Islamic jihad or ostriches. Oops, sorry, I offend the ostriches.
OLD GUY says
Islamic leaders are DICTATORS!
Frank Lord says
Islam is perpetuated by using young virgin women as reward in the form of a sexual slavery arranged marriages to middle aged Muslim men who bang on about how great their imaginary god is ..
There are no ghosts , no devils and no gods . Just horny old men ..
Sadly these greedy old men, sow the seeds of radicalism and terrorism to keep things as they are .. islamic terrorism and religious bigotry is inspired by the rantings of these old men hoping to get an arranged marriage.. old men marrying young women is totally wrong especially when these old perverts are stealing the young brides to be of young Muslim men who are left without a wife frustrated and angry .. very angry
I’ve interacted with a Muslim woman you’d call an influencer .. She started of very frosty and angry but after a duel of words, she I believe, realised that my comment actually overlaps with her own sense of injustice that she feels on behalf of young Muslims women who have been victims of arranged marriages ..
This is not racist ..
This an attempt to re – educate young Muslims ..
To stop the cycle of hatred for us, non Muslims, that enimates from their community . To stop the anger that young Muslim men and Women feel towards us .. An anger that has been instigated and perpetrated by middle aged men as a cover story for their path following a slave trader and slave taker who lived 1500 years ago ! Mohamed set into motion a system, whereby middle aged men can buy a young virgin to sexually abuse and enslave, for an affordable amount of money paid to the so called clerics, on the condition that the buyer sings praises to the system that enslaves these young women .. this cycle of hatred and anger that enslaves young women must be broken .. So much misery has been unleashed by this set of rules ..
Sharon says
The God of Israel Is Real.
Believe in His SON +
somehistory says
In my opinion on the matter, it’s punishment enough to be made to read, memorize and recite the demon filth.
How does this ghoul want those who make “errors” to be punished? Besides not being allowed to recite, what does he want done to them?
One of my older brothers was given a Bible for his recitation of some Scriptures he had memorized. I wasn’t in his Bible class, so I have no idea if he said it all perfectly. As Mr. Spencer wrote, there would not have been punishment had he erred.
Do mozlums who have different accents based on their country of origin and then moving to Egypt to recite have this counted against them?