Some more recent school news to fill you with despair can be found in this story from last April: “Studies in Macbeth’s toxicity and queer readings in leading private school’s diversity drive,” by Anna Davis, Evening Standard, April 13, 2023:
A leading London private school has overhauled its English curriculum to introduce a diverse range of authors and challenge “white-centric, patriarchal and cis-gender ideologies”.
Pupils at the £25,000-a-year Alleyn’s School in Dulwich now discuss Macbeth’s toxic masculinity and read The Tempest through the lens of colonialism.
Sixth formers study “queer readings” of A-level texts such as Dracula, and the first text by a non-binary author has been included in the A-level curriculum. Half of the books read by students in years seven, eight and nine are by female authors, which “helps in some way to counteract the lack of equality in the set texts for GCSE”.
A-level students must also choose one coursework text by a writer of colour “in an effort to tackle the lack of diversity in the A-level syllabus”.
Alex Smith, head of English at Alleyn’s, said the same texts — such as Macbeth, Lord of the Flies, Of Mice and Men and To Kill a Mockingbird — have been “wheeled out time and time again” for decades, propping up a “pale, male and stale” reading list.
Writing in a school blog she said: “For the last five years, the Alleyn’s English department have been committed to a thorough and ongoing overhaul and genuine diversification of our English curriculum in the hope that every child will come to see themselves [sic]…
In other words, pupils are presumed to be unable to engage with what they read, unless those readings are “by” or “about” people much like themselves. Students of color should be given the opportunity to read works by black authors, ideally with black protagonists. Female students should be able to read women authors and discuss, endlessly, issues of cis-gendered toxic masculinity. No pupil should be expected to expand his or her comprehension of the world through imaginative literature; the books to be read will be “fitted” to their readers, to hold their otherwise flagging attention. Required reading will be chosen on the basis not of literary merit but of sociological significance. “Pale, male, and stale” writers are rightly on the wane in the Alleyn’s School curriculum. There’s a lot less Shakespeare, Chaucer, and Keats, to make room for Malcolm X, Cornel West, Betty Friedan, and Rigoberta Menchu. And when those “pale, male, and stale” writers are read — they can’t be eliminated altogether, alas, at Alleyn’s they will serve as jumping-off points for discussion of today’s woke concerns — sexism, racism, colonialism..
As well as introducing a more diverse range of authors, Ms Smith said the school has also changed the way pupils study canonical texts by “white, cis-male authors”.
She wrote: “Whilst representation is of the utmost importance, discussions of racial and gender equality, and the challenging of white-centric, patriarchal, and cisgender ideologies can also happen while studying canonical texts by white, cis-male authors.”
Year seven pupils studying Shakespeare’s The Tempest “explore ideas about the effects and inherent problems of colonialism”, while year 12 pupils reading the 17th century revenge tragedy The Duchess of Malfi unpack “the patriarchal system that imprisons the duchess literally and figuratively.”
If our students must study some “white, cis-male [sic] authors,” at least — Ms. Smith insists — let class discussion focus not on the literary qualities of the works, but how those works can be used to engage with issues of “racial and gender equality.”
She added: “We are also committed to representing alternative versions of masculinity to those harmful tropes so often seen perpetuated in popular culture and by the media. The toxicity of Macbeth’s masculinity — and, crucially, its consequences — is central to our study of that text at GCSE.”
So Alleyn’s pupils will read Macbeth not to learn about the literary art with which he presents o’erweening ambition, murder, and guilt, but about “toxic masculinity.” Have the Alleyn’s teachers forgotten about the toxic femininity of Macbeth’s partner in crime, Lady Macbeth?
Forget about iambic pentameter, metonymy and metaphor, Shakespeare’s plangent playing on two lexical keyboards simultaneously — monosyllabic anglo-saxon words set off the polysyllabic words of Latinate origin (Ophelia speaking of Hamlet as “th’expectancy and rose of the fair state”; Macbeth’s “No; this my hand will rather/The multitudinous seas incarnadine/Making the green one red”). Such study contributes nothing to forging a society free of racism, sexism, and colonialism, which must be recognized as the true aim of education, at Alleyn’s School and no doubt, at many schools that will follow Alleyn’s School’s hideous example.
It comes after a report by campaign group End Sexism in Schools found that 77 per cent of novels studied by pupils in years seven, eight and nine are written by men, and 82 per cent of them have male protagonists. The group said that 99 per cent of plays taught to students in these year groups were by male writers.
77% of novels studied in years seven through nine are by men! And 82% of those have male protagonists! 99% of the plays taught in those same years are by men! An intolerable situation. So the Alleyn’s School teachers have spent hundreds of hours to prepare lessons on their new, much revised, list of required readings, so as to finally make a space — a very large space — in the curriculum for women writers, women writers of color, queer women writers of color. Down with the cis-gendered white male! Up with everyone else!
Pupils at Alleyn’s will now read The Tempest in order to “explore ideas about the effects and inherent problems of colonialism.” They will read The Duchess of Malfi to “unpack” the patriarchal system that imprisons the duchess. They will read Othello to engage with toxic masculinity and racism. They will read Hamlet to study family dysfunction. They will pay no attention to Shakespeare’s literary artifice: it’s only the “ideas” in the plays that speak to us today that matter.
Get with the program. Jump on the Juggernaut. Don’t be left behind. Remember, “pale, male, and stale” are out. Diversity, Equity, and Inclusivity are all ye know on earth, and all ye need to know.
Bexarkat says
I can’t wait to see what they do to the Merchant of Venice! They’ll likely transform Shylock to a poor Moorish peasant who is actually the victim of whiteness.
Treereen says
“Pupils at the £25,000-a-year Alleyn’s School in Dulwich now discuss Macbeth’s toxic masculinity and read The Tempest through the lens of colonialism.”
To be a woke pu**y, or not to be a woke pu**y? That is a rhetorical question.
—–
It’d be interesting to find out how many parents pulled their children out of that school once the new “silly bus” was unveiled. For £25,000 a year I’d expect classics across the board, not current state school swill.
—–
How will that process be applied to sciences? Hmmm…, let’s resort to whimsy:
Mathematics – if one dog can round up 10 sheep, how many sheep can 3 dogs round up? depends on how many black sheep there are because they have to be treated with kid gloves due to “lived experiences”.
Physics – design a magnetic envelope configuration to let black electrons through unhindered but cause white electrons to slow down, apologise for existing in the first place and leave their shoes at the entrance.
Chemistry – use a reagent to turn calcium carbonate any colour but white, preferably transparent so, it disappears.
—–
I really do hope the woke pu**ies won’t expect all the “toxic masculinity” to save their vegan bacon in a future war, which doesn’t appear to be that far away.
Mary Markstrom says
If they want to study toxic masculinity then Malcolm X is a perfect example. He was the biggest mysogynist I can think of.
Andy Paul says
Isn’t it reasonable and normal in what remains a white majority nation to have a “white centric” syllabus?