They have committed him to psychiatric care, because they can’t admit to themselves or anyone else that a reader of the Qur’an might get the idea that he should do violence to those who do not read it.
“Knife attack at Bonnevay station in Villeurbanne: Sultan Niazi will not be sentenced,” translated from “Attaque au couteau à la station Bonnevay à Villeurbanne: Sultan Niazi ne sera pas condamné,” Le Progrès, March 29, 2022 (thanks to Medforth):
[…] On August 31, 2019, a man caused a panic at the Laurent-Bonnevay bus station in Villeurbanne. Sultan Mohamed Niazi had just attacked fourteen passers-by with a kitchen knife and a barbecue fork. Timothy Bonnet, 19, who had been attacked from behind, died of his injuries. Eight other people had been hit and injured.
Unsurprisingly, the schizophrenic attacker was declared criminally not liable. He is currently in solitary confinement in Corbas prison and will be committed to psychiatric care, probably in a unit for the seriously disturbed (UMD), as his condition is increasingly deteriorating. The decision was announced by the Investigatory Chamber […] on Tuesday.
“The family feared it, the decision fell: the killer of Timothy Bonnet will not be judged,” translated from “La famille le redoutait, la décision est tombée : le tueur de Timothy Bonnet ne sera pas jugé,” by Gabrielle Cluzel, Boulevard Voltaire, March 29, 2022:
Sultan Niazi, who, on August 31, 2019, killed Timothy Bonnet, 19, at the Laurent-Bonnevay metro station in Villeurbanne, will not ultimately be judged: Justice having recognized him as criminally irresponsible, he will be interned in a psychiatric hospital. Régine Bonnet, the grandmother of the young man – valiant mother of eight children – who learned about it from the press, has a broken voice on the phone. For her, it is “as if Timothy was killed a second time.” Of course, as his son says, a judgment wouldn’t have given Timothy back to them. But she feels “robbed.” She looks back on the route of this 34-year-old Afghan migrant, drug addict, who first arrived ten years ago in France, then transited through Italy, the United Kingdom… before returning to France. It was because he thought he saw in Timothy an individual who had insulted him in England – Timothy never set foot there – that he stabbed him. And also because “voices” have ordered him to execute those who do not “read the Koran.” Eight other people were injured, Timothy, who had come from Savoy to go to the Woodstower music festival in Lyon, succumbed. Holder of two CAPs, in bakery and chocolate – because he was the “best student, he had been appointed to do a month’s internship in the kitchens of the Élysée under François Hollande” – he was training as a caterer. at the time of the tragedy. “He deserved a good life,” adds his grandmother, sadly.
somehistory says
the poor teenager, Timothy, deserved so much better.
And this mozlum terrorist has earned himself a place of destruction. It would take a lot of real repentance to save his ugly hide, and he’s not likely to ever feel sorry or guilty for murdering a young man who did him no harm.
mozlums such as this slime, have made themselves the children of satan the devil. As Jesus said, “You are from your father the devil and you wish to do the desires of your father. that one was a murderer from his beginning ..a liar and the father of the lie; and he does not stand fast in the Truth.”
Humans who make themselves children of satan, will face the same end.
Arthur J Thornton says
You hit the nail on the head!!!
somehistory says
Thank you!
Jim says
I am sure there are also non-Muslims who become insane and behave like that. But it does seem wrong for the representatives of Islam to encourage such behavior in their mosques, cultural centers, internet sites, and other venues. They should be condemning and discouraging it. A friend told me it was not Muslims who did this, but rather radical extremists. However, these extremists are very often Muslim radical extremists. It is a shame that this religion is doing to much harm. If they could be discouraged from coming to the West or if they could be discouraged from acting this way in the West.
Arthur J Thornton says
thet can’t be kept out as long as politicians can’t say “muslim extremist” like Barac Obama & his ilk & God help ‘U.S.” & the whole world if they get full control of any where they live!!!
Sudha Satish says
They are destroying India too! Why only the West, they should be prohibited from going anywhere. 56 islamic countries is a lot of choice!
gravenimage says
Pious Muslims are a threat all over the world.
Arthur J Thornton says
Weak minded yellow belly back boned jelly liberal politicians & judges act like they don’t know how to read themselves to know what islam & the quran is all about!!! Lok at their history, past present & future!!!
nicholas tesdorf says
The only aspect of this judgement that could be called rational is that belief in Islam is a form of insanity and this perpetrator of violence belongs permanently in psychiatric care, for the safety of the Public.
gravenimage says
France: Afghan Muslim migrant stabs people who ‘do not read the Quran’: judges say he’s not criminally liable
……………
Suicidal insanity. No doubt he will be declared sane and released in a couple of years…
James Lincoln says
Yes, gravenimage.
And, after he is released, he will likely go “off his meds”… with predictable results.
gravenimage says
All too likely, James.
Kenneth J Johnson says
i AGREE THAT MOST OF THESE MUSLEMS WHO ATTACH PEOPLE AT RANDOM ARE NOT MENTALLY ALL THERE., Thanks to inbreeding and a lifetijme of listeing to “Teachers) ( Imans) who are themselves unbalanced The disease is so deep rooted that the prognosis for change is between slim and none. Therefore, to protect sociey prison is a reasonable alternative to other choices,. KEN
gravenimage says
Ken, there are other groups–the Amish, certain sects of Judaism–who do a lot of intermarrying, ye thtye ate not out stabbing people. Really, thinking that violence towards unbelievers has nothing to do with Jihad terror I’m afraid makes no sense.
Spideyweb1 says
Time to petition congress to declare Islam a determination to one’s mental functioning in all societies. They keep saying these Muslims are mentally unstable. So where do these people become corrupted? Ahhhhh, Quran? Yeah..
Johnny B says
If the Quran is so dangerous, that mentally ill people become terrorists, why don’t they ever talk about banning the parts that trigger these people? You can’t just say because these people are mentally ill, it has nothing to do with Islam when all of them get the murderous ideas from Islamic scriptures.