My latest reply to Stephen Schwartz is up today at FrontPage along with an extended essay from Mustafa Akyol on the same topic: the reformation of Islam. Akyol here argues that the Hadith and Sira should be jettisoned, leaving only the Qur’an. He seems to be suggesting that virtually all the features of Islam that […]
Bat Ye’or vs. Mustafa Akyol on Islam’s “Golden Age”
The peerless historian Bat Ye’or replies to Muslim apologist Mustafa Akyol at FrontPage today. Akyol and I, of course, have carried on a dialogue here and at FrontPage. Score now: jihadists 5, Akyol 0. From Bat Ye’or: The hope inspired by Mr. Mustafa Akyol’s long article in Front Page Magazine is tempered by his deception. […]
Schwartz on the “Islamic Reformation”
Stephen Schwartz has published a reflection on the need for a reformation of Islam in Tech Central Station (via FrontPage). Not long ago I took issue with one of his pieces claiming that Wahhabis were essentially revising the Qur’an to make it more anti-Jewish and anti-Christian; I pointed out that the Wahhabis were working from […]
Cairo Conference: Reform Islam. Al-Azhar: Not So Fast
In Islam Unveiled I discuss why Islamic reformers will always face an uphill battle: whenever they attempt to depart from Qur’anic literalism, they become vulnerable to charges from radicals of infidelity to Islam. This poses what is probably an insurmountable problem for those who would reform Islam. Why, then, have I called for such reform […]
Al-Qaeda vs. the Qur’an?
In NRO Mustafa Akyol has replied to Andrew McCarthy‘s criticism of his initial piece claiming that radical Muslims were violating tenets of Islam by beheading hostages. My own initial reply to Akyol is here. Looks like it’s time for another long post. My apologies. I have been criticized by people I respect recently for making […]
Muslim Creed: Are Martyrdom Operations Lawful (According to Quran and Sunnah)?
We hear constantly from Islamic apologists and people who ought to know better about how the Qur’an forbids suicide, as if that is the last word about suicide attacks carried out by Muslims. But when Muslims speak to their fellow Muslims, instead of to Western unbelievers anxious to be reassured that all that we are […]
Straight Path of Islam: “Jew Producing Fake Quran”
Some time ago someone signed me up for a message board entitled “The Straight Path of Islam.” It is often fascinating as a glimpse into the jihadist mindset, and to Muslim attitudes in general. The post below was sent out to alert Muslims to false Qur’anic passages that are circulating; the sender says they are […]
Imam lets muezzin beat his wife
In Islam Unveiled I discuss the widespread acceptance of wife-beating in the Islamic world, stemming from the Qur’anic sanction given it in Sura 4:34. Here is further confirmation that this practice is still widely accepted, and a welcome indication that the light of world opinion shining on this practice (witness the fact of the article […]
The Quran mentions beheading. Why does the U.S. press claim otherwise?
Has Lee Smith of Slate been reading Jihad Watch? In this article (thanks to nevermindlv for the link) he quotes two Qur’anic verses sanctioning beheading that I quoted here, and he points out, as I have many times, that the media, American Muslim spokesmen, and their dhimmi allies routinely lie about what the Qur’an really […]
The Qur’an and Anti-Semitism
This morning at Front Page there is a symposium on the Qur’an and anti-Semitism, featuring Islamic reform advocate Professor Khaleel Mohammed, the renowned scholar Bat Ye’or, and Jihad Watch director Robert Spencer. I think it is illuminating in several important ways. Read the whole thing; here are my closing remarks: Spencer: I thank Professor Muhammad […]